Skip to Main Navigation

The Buffalo News

Web Search
by YAHOO! SEARCH

Commentary

Fans' fury deserves an answer

News NHL Columnist

Published:January 24, 2012, 11:36 PM

Font Size:
  • E-mail
  • Share
  • Print

Recent Bucky Gleason Columns

Updated: January 24, 2012, 11:36 PM

Some might be surprised and perhaps offended, but I've never been one to read comments after my columns and rarely put much stock into what people say in emails. I toss reactions into the same jar. Fans are passionate about sports and have strong opinions. We have that much in common.

Buffalo fans pay attention, and many make valid points while telling me why they disagree with me or remind me when I miss something. Some have called me names I wouldn't repeat at a bachelor party. It comes with the job.

What irks me is when people accuse me of writing something I didn't write, then blast me under false pretenses. There's plenty of real material for people to second-guess, let alone things they imagined or heard that I said.

And that brings me to my column Sunday about the Sabres and my opinion that General Manager Darcy Regier should be fired. Just so you know, there's no joy in calling for someone's job.

Regier is a good man with a family. Personally, I like him and respect him. Professionally, I think he needs to be replaced.

Reaction to the column was interesting if not entertaining, and it sparked arguments among several readers.

Here are a few cut-and-paste excerpts of comments posted, emails and tweets afterward with my response.

In an article prior to the season, Most of the article was about getting Brad Richards who did not give Buffalo the time of day but "Power Play: Bucky Gleason plays GM for a day" ... Bucky reviews his plan and year to year advice:

"In 2008, as GM my main focus was getting Miller signed, probably 5.8 mill ... "Kevin Biecksa [sic] would have been my first choice but not available [sic]... so sign Christian Ehrhoff."

Pegula, (my main man Terry Gleason called him) (sic) has the brains, charisma and backbone to run this organization ... "Ville Leino is an underrated jewel and will be a UFA ... sign him."

Before you continue blabbering on about telling owners, Gm, coaches and players how to do their job ... learn your own craft. — JEFFREY GIANCARLO, LANCASTER, NY

Jeffrey, do your homework. All the quotes imply that's what I wrote, but that's not the case at all. Here's the link: http://www.buffalonews.com/sports/col

umns/bucky-gleason/article472336.ece.

Here's exactly what I wrote, as it pertained to Miller: "In 2008, my plan called for dumping [Maxim] Afinogenov, re-signing Ryan Miller for $5.6 million a year and signing free-agent defenseman Brooks Orpik."

What's the difference, you ask? Try $1 million, or the $200,000 gap between what Jeffrey claimed and what actually was written, over the course of Miller's five-year contract. The difference between what I suggested and what Miller was paid ($6,250,000 annually) is $3.25 million. But what's a few million bucks between friends?

My thoughts on Ehrhoff: "I really wanted Kevin Bieksa but he took less to stay in Vancouver. I would have taken Eric Brewer, but he's gone. I'm now down to James Wisniewski, who I could have had straight up for Connolly before he signed that foolish two-year deal for $9 million, or Christian Ehrhoff."

Ehrhoff was no better than my fourth choice, after three tougher defensemen.

What I actually wrote about Leino: "Ville Leino is an underrated jewel who is scheduled to become an unrestricted free agent. He emerged in the playoffs with Detroit, continued his success with the Flyers and can play on the second and third lines. He can help in many areas, especially with the right players around him. He made $800,000. He's worth $3 million. I would be willing to shuffle around money to sign him, but it depends on whether or not I sign Richards. Leino comes with an asterisk."

The difference: Leino is making $4.5 million per season. Over the course of his six-year contract, the Sabres are paying him $9 million more than what I suggested. The key was getting the right players around him, namely a proven center.

By the way, I still don't see Leino as a bust. If he plays this way for the next several years, my opinion will change. Daniel Briere was considered a major mistake in his first year in Philadelphia. Not anymore.

.  . .

A SABRE FAN SINCE OCTOBER 1970. I CAN NOT TAKE THIS SEASON ANY MORE. KEEP ROOTING FOR THE OTHER TEAM, HOPE THAT SOMETHING WILL BE DONE. A TRADE OR BETTER YET A CLEAN HOUSE OF COACH AND GM. I STILL LOVE THE SABRES. BUT I HAVE REACHED MY BREAKING POINT. I AM NOT A FAIR WEATHER FAN EITHER. I HAVE TONS OF SABRE ITEMS. PROGRAMS, AUTOGRAPHS, ETC. CAN NOT EVEN WATCH OTHER GAMES. WHAT IS [TERRY] PEGULA WAITING FOR? — Mark, via email.

Mark, you're either VERY upset or your Caps Lock is stuck. It happens to me ALL THE TIME. Here's my read on the situation: Pegula said Ruff and Regier "ain't goin' nowhere," and he's not making a U-turn any time soon. Pegula believes injuries were an important factor in the Sabres' problems this season, and he wants to see them with a healthy lineup before making a full evaluation of his entire organization. I can't see him making major changes until after the season at the earliest.

. . . .

My guess is that Brian Burke won't let [Rick] Dudley go from the Leafs org, being a Darcy fan and all. — @thomkrauss, via Twitter.

@thomkrauss, I'm really not sure. First, the Sabres would need to remove Regier before pursuing anyone else. They would need permission from the Leafs to speak to Dudley, who is under contract as an assistant GM. Dudley might not even want the job. To me, he looks like a good fit because he built, or helped build, several good teams. He has experience, knows the league inside and out, knows the Sabres and understands Buffalo.

. . . .

I enjoy your reads as a sports analyst mixed with proper proportions of hometown fan raw emotion. Take a pill on this one. He's going to do what needs to be done. It's clear Sabres' brass knee jerked last off season and spent money unwisely. (Imagine the headlines if Darcy was handed a blank check and didn't spend it?) To compound that knee-jerk with another is simply foolish. — DAN NILES, RALEIGH, NC

Dan, you make several good points. FYI: I still have faith in Pegula. The Sabres didn't spend wisely because they were forced to overpay players. They had a serious recruiting problem and needed to improve their reputation. You're right, Regier would have been vilified if he didn't spend to the cap, or near the cap.

But to suggest I had a knee-jerk reaction is inaccurate, in my opinion. I've been covering Regier since he arrived and thought he should have been fired several times over the years. That's not a knee-jerk reaction.

That's just my reaction.

bgleason@buffnews.comnull

true

Comments

Sort:NEWEST FIRST | OLDEST FIRST

I am not a fan of Gleason or his acid like incendiary dribble. Yes there were big expectations at the start of this season.We all had them. And we are all dissapointed by the results so far. But to publicly make some of the Statements Gleason has made about this owner and his decisions only 3 months into this season are shameful. When this team begins to turn it around (this season or next) and show what they are made of Gleason DO NOT compliment or write favorably because you can't have it both ways. Sports Teams,The Stock Market, and the Weather have ups and downs. Quit whining and learn some Journalistic moderation and civility. Consider yourself lucky you still have press access to the team.

BEN DEFOREST, MASSILLON, OH on Wed Feb 1, 2012 at 08:58 PM

@Dan N.: If "the devil you know" only continues to do things the same old way time after time, I'd much rather take a chance with "the devil you don't know."

LLOYD MARSHALL, LOCKPORT, NY on Sat Jan 28, 2012 at 04:17 PM

Hey Buck, thanks for the response. It's good (and healthy) to take an interest in your readership. I think you mistook the knee-jerk comment, but no big deal. I enjoy the exchange and your content.

No doubt suffering through 50 years of what has been mostly dismal news with respect to Buffalo sports would dampen even the most ardent of optimists. I'm right there with everyone but I'm trying to change.

Take a step back from the ledge for a second, you too, Bucky, and take a look at what we have here. We finally have an owner that is willing to do whatever it takes. That's something we have never had.

Look at what else we have. We have the opportunity to talk about a Zach Parise and actually mean it! We have an opportunity to actually consider buyouts of ill-conceived contracts. We also have an organization that has had its marching orders completely transformed and only 11 months of experience with those new orders. Large organizations, by their nature, can't turn on a dime. Cultures that have been in place for more than 10 years don't change overnight.

I contend that rash decisions have put this team where it's at right now. Compounding that with more rash decisions is illogical. I am not advocating blind faith in Ruff and Regier. But doing something right now, just for the sake of doing something, means you have learned nothing. Finish the season and make carefully considered judgements during the off-season. Then after careful consideration, if the best move is to let one or both go, do it. Remember sometimes the devil you do know is better than one you don't.

DAN NILES, RALEIGH, NC on Sat Jan 28, 2012 at 11:21 AM

I completely understand the foul mood Sabre Fans are in, but lets look at this rationally. First: just like John Adams made his midnight appointments, so too did the previous ownership, by giving Darcy a contract extension before transfering ownership to Terry Pegula. So we're stuck with Darcy for now. All of us love to point to Darcy's take your time approach to making trades or is it not moving as quickly as we want. Yes it may be a fault and Darcy does need to shoulder some of the blame for the Drury/Briere incident. But lets also remember that he was the reason both we're here. Is it time for Darcy to move on, probally, but he is one person I would want scouting talent for this organization. As for a replacement, the hot name seems to be Rick Dudley. Yes he understands Buffalo Hockey and has the experience, but why has he been let go after helping to build teams? What I would like to see is someone come in from an organization with a recent winning tradition, Pittsburgh, Philly or Detroit. Jason Botterill is currently assistant GM in Pittsburgh and Don Luce is with Philly, both would be good choices, both come from winning organizations, both have ties to this organization. Pegula loves the Buffalo connection but with strong ties to the Penguins, I would put my money on Jason Botterill. When would this happen? End of the season, with a new CBA on the horizon, new cap and new divisional alignment, lets go in a new direction.

THOMAS DURLAK, CHEEKTOWAGA, NY on Fri Jan 27, 2012 at 11:38 AM

I think a vacuum cleaner could have coached a team with Dominic Hasek to 200 wins and a trip to the 1999 finals. Just like my Grandma could have coached those Montreal teams in the 70s to cup wins like Scotty Bowman.

MATT TRIPPI, PALMYRA, NY on Thu Jan 26, 2012 at 11:10 PM

oooo comments are gettin racy !

MICHAEL VANWAGENEN, CONCORD, NC on Thu Jan 26, 2012 at 03:14 PM

Dan Foy go talk teacher of ledge maybe ledge will break and then there will be 1 less person who no nothing about hockey. I am sure there are many people who got the point. Also your comparison to old-time Indian I would read you as a raciest person.
Thanks for your comment Dan Foy RACIEST in Asheville, NC

KENNETH LOMBARD, KEARNEY, on Thu Jan 26, 2012 at 02:16 PM

Kenneth Lombard write like old-time Indian movie stereotype. Heap big grammatical errors make Kemosabe wonder what the he11 he talk about. He say Jeff Giancarlo miss point, but me wonder how Jeff even come up with point in first place.

Hey, Kenneth, your 9th grade English teacher called and wants to be talked down from the ledge after reading your "commentary".

Me anticipate Kenneth probably say Kemosabe know nothing about hockey and is starry-eyed fan who believe anything Chief Pegula tell him. Me say Kenneth should make point in English and not Twitter tongue.

DAN FOY, ASHEVILLE, NC on Thu Jan 26, 2012 at 01:15 AM

Forget about the past, let's think about now, I really don't even care to think about Tom Golisano and his sidekick Larry Quinn. How is Darcy going to bring in star talent so we can win a cup? Poor Lindsey Ruff has had no talent, oh boo hoo. The NJ Devils won cups through the draft and spending less money but they have an outstanding GM. The Sabres have a GM who loves to keep things the same, I have news for Darcy, Ted Black said most teams change up their rosters every 2-3 years so he better get with the program, this core of wimps is never going to even win one single playoff round.

Why in the world would any Sabres fan want this team to make a run for the playoffs? It would be far better for us to miss and get a top 5 draft pick.

Darcy has way too many excuses and rules, he has all the money in the world now and even said he wants the NHL to change the rules allowing money to be send with trades.

1. he only wants to lock up guys long term, he doesn't want any guys only here for a few years. why? Veterans for the cup run have been done for 50 years and worked

2. trades he claims don't work even though he has never tried any during a season. Boston made trades and won the cup just like all the other teams that win do.

3. he said he wants to stay away from Russian players in the draft. I guess he is a prejudice guy.

He has too many rules and excuses, time to go.

MATT TRIPPI, PALMYRA, NY on Wed Jan 25, 2012 at 08:30 PM

Hello Jeff all well in NB. I think you missed my point I did give Ruff credit for the good years . I said the 99 team was a Nolan team, He has had good season not good enough to win the prize. As for the players on ice you are right they are eather going to win u games or lose. I think the cast of players we have except for a 1 or 2 maybe 3 ROY, WEBER, SEKERA can win not good enough to win cup. Couple of trades good draft choices that will mix with the existing cast. My point is when the players don't or won't play to there potential it falls back to the coach as u no u can't trade the whole team right. My point ( I said I do not believe this group going to nor do they want play for Ruff anymore). All what they could have done in trades, FA, Drafts, What they should have done is hind sight can't live in the past. What lies ahead is on the GM he has given Ruff what he thought Ruff could work with. So that said GM made bad decisions or Ruff can't coach anymore I do not think that is true, I also do not think GM made all bad decisions could have been better but it is what is. So here lies decisions trade team no, Fire coach option, Fire GM option or if you have 3 billion dollars as we no the owner has and the fans are filling your building for a losing team why change until u have til. Remember when Pegula bought the team he said it was a dream come true to own an NHL franchise the Buffalo Sabers loved all the players from the 70's & 80's. 200 or 250 million means nothing to him. No mater what happens during his ownership he will always be able to say I own or owned an NHL franchise. Hitchcock, Boudreau, Hunter Hitchcock has worked since day 1, Boudreau and Hunter took a little longer but its working now. Change ok

KENNETH LOMBARD, KEARNEY, on Wed Jan 25, 2012 at 06:54 PM

1 2 3
Add your comment

Real Estate Transactions »

Search our home sales transactions database that contains the selling price of every home in Erie County since 2006.

Advanced search »

Blogs

Sports, Ink

This Day in Buffalo Sports History: One nice night

Prep Talk

Dunkirk forward punched by East player

Sabres Edge

Vote for your three stars

Sports Updates

The Feed / What’s Happening Now

Latest Updates
Most Commented
Most Viewed
Sabres & NHL

Sabres, Miller jump for Roy in shootout

Bills & NFL

Bills need to take step, but won't reach

Sabres & NHL

Sabres let a point slip away in overtime

Bucky Gleason

Five-point gap in race more than a stretch

Bills & NFL

Progress made in talks with Johnson

Southern Tier

Accusation of crack pipe in bra leads to new charge

Niagara Falls

Falls man charged in rape of girl, 14

Margaret Sullivan

Okun steps away from the table

North Buffalo/Hertel

Zoo opens doors to protect a rare breed

Weather

High winds drop trees, but snow stays behind

Buffalo Marketplace

Marketplace videos

Watch the latest offers, products and services from our advertisers.

Browse our print ads

It's the ultimate advantage for Buffalo consumers. Never miss another ad again!

Buffalo Savers: coupons

Buffalo coupons at your fingertips.
Just click and print. It's Easy!

close

Browse our print adsclose

Special Sections

Buffalo Saversclose

Local coupons

Featured coupon