Skip to Main Navigation

The Buffalo News

Web Search
by YAHOO! SEARCH

Question Mark: AFL isn't under-represented

Published:October 23, 2009, 10:22 PM

Font Size:
  • E-mail
  • Share
  • Print

Updated: August 21, 2010, 8:54 AM

The News' Mark Gaughan answers your questions.

Q: You said Tom Sestak didn't play long enough to earn enshrinement in the Hall of

Fame. That's interesting as there are others that played less, yet made it. What you should

have said was Tom didn't play any games after the merger to "legitimize" his career against

NFL talent. ... I visited the HOF on Kelly's induction and was appalled by the lack of equal

representation from the AFL. — Mike Powenski.

A: My short answer is: The AFL is slightly under-represented in the Hall. But only slightly.

Let's compare the numbers. For the first six years of the "60s there were 14 NFL teams and

eight AFL teams. By 1967 it was 16 vs. 9, then it went to 16 vs. 10. So the NFL had a little

less than double the number of players. You'd expect it would have a little less than double

the number of Hall of Famers. Also the AFL was a start-up league so it took several years,

let's say until 1963 or '64, for the caliber of play to be equal to the NFL.

Complicating the comparison is the obvious fact the NFL existed before 1960 and the AFL

didn't. With that in mind, here we go: There are 14 AFL players who served four or more years

in the Hall. If you count guys who played three or two seasons (including guys like Willie

Lanier and Gene Upshaw), the AFL has 23 Hall members. Using that same criteria of players who

started in 1960 or later, the NFL has 25 players with four-plus years and 30 players if you

count those who started in 1967 or 1968. That's 14 vs. 25; or 23 vs. 30. There are four more

NFL players in the Hall whose careers started in 1958. There are another six whose careers

started in 1957 (including Jim Brown and Paul Hornung).

I'd put Chiefs safety Johnny Robinson at the top of the list of AFL guys who should be in.

Next would be ex-Raiders personnel man Ron Wolf. No. 3 would be Chiefs OT Jim Tyrer and then

Chiefs WR Otis Taylor. Broncos RB Floyd Little is a candidate this year. He's borderline.

Patroits DT Houston Antwine and Denver WR Lionel Taylor are close. But former News columnist

Larry Felser puts them in the Hall of Very Good, not the Hall of Fame. I've given my two cents

on Sestak. I respect your right to disagree.

Q: Does the NFL have the same rules leaguewide for what is allowed to be brought into

stadiums? For instance the Bills allow no bags larger than 12 inches square, but in Oakland

you can bring in shoulder pads with huge spikes affixed to them. Does each franchise make its

rules? — Greg Kozak.

A: I'm told the NFL gives each franchise "best practices" guidelines that it strongly

recommends, and those are widely followed throughout the league. So it's about the same in

every city. Oakland has a habit of doing things its own way, but I'm not sure about its

guidelines.

Q: With the new rule regarding no force-outs on receptions, why don't defensive backs

practice catching receivers when they are up in the air near the sidelines and carrying them

out of bounds? — Cal Tuohey, Medina.

A: That's a no-no. NFL officials have the leeway to rule a receiver in bounds if the defender

uses a "catch and carry" tactic. If a player catches the ball and is actually picked up and

carried out of bounds by a defender, it can still be called a catch. Shoving, pushing and

nudging once the receiver catches the ball all are fair game for defenders.

Bills beat reporter Mark Gaughan answers your football questions every Friday, online and

in the paper. Send your e-mails to mgaughan@buffnews.com, or join his live chat at 11 a.m. on

the BillBoard blog.

Comments

There are no comments on this story.

Blogs

Prep Talk

PrepTalkTV: Big night for St. Joe's on court & ice, plus more highlights & a look at hoops' final week

Campus Watch

Niagara-Siena Game Analysis

Sports, Ink

This Day in Buffalo Sports History: Quirk of fate

Sports Updates

Sports Wire

The Feed / What’s Happening Now

Latest Updates
Most Commented
Most Viewed
Sabres & NHL

Sabres show some gumption in beating Bruins

East Side

Police raids target massive drug ring

Batavia/Genesee County

Woman, 24, found dead in car

Courts

White firefighters are awarded $2.7 million in bias case

City & Region

Catholic institutions here cover birth control

Bills & NFL

Bills hire a quarterback mechanic in Lee

Student illnesses in Le Roy

Answers to the many questions in Le Roy

Bucky Gleason

Sabres find the missing ingredients

Rod Watson

Lady Justice’s blindfold gets thrown away

Buffalo Marketplace

Marketplace videos

Watch the latest offers, products and services from our advertisers.

Browse our print ads

It's the ultimate advantage for Buffalo consumers. Never miss another ad again!

Buffalo Savers: coupons

Buffalo coupons at your fingertips.
Just click and print. It's Easy!

close

Browse our print adsclose

Special Sections

Buffalo Saversclose

Local coupons

Featured coupon