Skip to Main Navigation

The Buffalo News

Web Search
by YAHOO! SEARCH

Proposal would allow 'fracking' in state

Recommendations spare public land, watersheds

News Business Reporter

Published:June 30, 2011, 11:52 PM

Font Size:
  • E-mail
  • Share
  • Print

Updated: July 1, 2011, 8:10 AM

The state is opening the door to a surge in natural gas drilling with the end of a moratorium across much of upstate New York on a controversial method called hydraulic fracturing to extract large volumes of natural gas from shale.

The state Department of Environmental Conservation said Thursday it will release new recommendations today on the horizontal drilling version of the technique, which uses millions of gallons of water, treated with sand and chemicals, under high pressure to unlock natural gas trapped in shale thousands of feet below ground.

The DEC proposal would permit drilling on private land "under rigorous and effective controls." The rules would ban such drilling on public lands and in the Syracuse and New York City watersheds.

Arguing that it would contaminate water supplies, environmentalists have lobbied against the practice, now allowed in Pennsylvania.

The DEC said the rules would give drillers access to about 85 percent of the state's Marcellus Shale, the gas-rich layer of rock long coveted by the natural gas industry. It would clear the way for drilling throughout a wide swath of the Southern Tier and Central New York, where geologists say they believe large amounts of natural gas are trapped within layers of dark shale.

"The report strikes the right balance between protecting our environment, watersheds and drinking water, and promoting economic development," said Joseph Martens, the state's commissioner of environmental conservation.

Drilling supporters said ending the moratorium could bring an economic boom to the state, with thousands of jobs, while opponents worry that the technique, commonly called "fracking," could cause significant environmental damage.

"It's been a long time, and I think New York has missed out on a huge amount of economic benefit," said John C. Holko, president of Lenape Resources, a natural gas driller in Alexander.

"It's been a long time coming," said S. Dennis Holbrook, executive vice president of Norse Energy Holdings in Hamburg. "As long as we safeguard the quality of the environment, the potential economic benefits are enormous."

Environmentalists were disappointed.

"It's a shame," said Robert M. Ciesielski, the chairman of the Sierra Club, Niagara Group. "There are serious health problems and public health problems with the waste from the drilling."

But the rush to drill would not start immediately. Today's release of the DEC findings, which run more than 1,000 pages, will precede a 60-day public comment period to begin in August next month. The DEC then will review those comments and make final revisions before issuing any drilling permits.

As a result, Holbrook said no horizontal drilling is likely to begin in the state until next year. 2012 He also predicted it would ramp up more slowly than in Pennsylvania, where more than 3,300 such wells have been sunk in recent years.

"I think it will be the most elaborate, well-thought-out set of regulations," Holbrook said. "It may be a bit overburdensome, but it will be the gold standard" for natural gas drilling rules.

Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, D-Manhattan, said ending the moratorium was premature.

"There are simply too many unknowns to risk inflicting long-term, potentially catastrophic damage to New York's environment and water supply," he said. "At a minimum, New York should wait until the [U.S. Environmental Protection Agency] completes its own study on hydraulic fracturing before even considering whether the state should permit this type of drilling activity."

The end of the moratorium is not expected lead to a drilling boom in Western New York, except for a swath along the southeastern corner of Allegany County, geologists and industry officials said.

Geologists say that, unlike the layer across much of Central New York, the Marcellus Shale throughout most of the western part of the state is too thin and shallow to hold vast quantities of natural gas.

But other geologic formations, including the Utica Shale that lies thousands of feet below the Marcellus, could hold promise for drilling in Western New York many years from now, industry officials said.

Drilling opponents have argued that the large amounts of water and potentially harmful chemicals used in hydraulic fracturing could pose a threat to drinking water supplies. Ciesielski cited issues with adequate treatment of wastewater and the proper disposal of the solid waste from the process.

Energy industry officials, however, contend that the moratorium cost the state thousands of badly needed jobs and preventing the development of a natural resource that could reduce energy costs and ease the dependence on energy imports.

The moratorium did not stop the drilling of vertical gas wells, the type that has been sunk throughout Western New York for the better part of two centuries. Most of those wells also are hydraulically fractured -- and continue to be -- but they use less than 80,000 gallons of water in the process.

The moratorium had covered the most controversial version of hydraulic fracturing, which involves horizontal wells like those that now are being drilled in Pennsylvania.

Those wells go straight down for about a mile, then gradually turn at almost a 90-degree angle and continue for a half mile to nearly a mile horizontally, through the Marcellus Shale.

Drillers then inject millions of gallons of water, chemically treated to kill bacteria and prevent scale from building up on the pipes, into the well at high pressure to produce tiny cracks in the rock to free the gas. Drillers also use small explosive charges.

The technique allows drillers to tap into much larger supplies of gas from a single drill site, which can have as many as six wells extending out in different directions. A single well can cost upwards of $4 million, but successful wells can produce gas at very high rates.

Industry officials have stressed that tens of thousands of vertical natural gas wells have been drilled safely throughout New York, and most of those drilled in the last three decades or so have been hydraulically fractured.

drobinson@buffnews.comnull

true

Comments

Sort:NEWEST FIRST | OLDEST FIRST

As for the extension of the moratorium, even though it passed the assembly, you can thank all of your local politicians who, even though they are in the assembly, voted NO to extend the moratorium. It was the assembly representatives in central NY that got it passed. Not WNY. The following voted NO, Corwin, Smardz, and Schroeder. In the Senate, the following would have voted NO, Gallivan and Maziarz (who wants to bring the waste water to Tonawanda & Niagara Falls). Interestingly enough, only Schroeder met with the constituents opposed to fracking personally. We know that they were all lobbied by the gas industry at least 4 times, I wonder if they met with them personally? The other thing is, this industry continues to give misinformation and overly inflates all their numbers. How can anyone say that this is not safe to drill near NYC and Syracuse but could care less about the rest of New York, the Great Lakes, and the welfare of their constituents who can't afford to protect their property or right to clean air and water? Interestingly enough, as well, the chemists from the Niagara Falls waste water treatment plant was called up to Albany this week to speak with Cuomo possibly to see if Maziarz wish to bring the toxic radioactive mix here. Ohio said NO to the waste water two weeks ago.

SHEILA MILLER, ORCHARD PARK, NY on Mon Jul 4, 2011 at 09:10 AM

Toxic in Tonawanda

UPDATE

Ohio Mainstream Residents Speaks Out To New York

Re Ohio : Article in the" Buffalo News" / Proposal Would Allow Fracking In New York

SO, WHERE WILL ALL THE MILLIONS ( BILLIONS) OF GALLONS OF RADIOACTIVE FLOWBACK GO TO FOR DISPOSAL FROM NEW YORK STATE? We heard that it is highly unlikely that they would allow it to be injected there, and PA's geology isn't conducive....SO, it will ALL come to Ohio?

Note: Article indicates BANS TO PREVENT DRILLING IN TWO WATER SHEDS IN NEW YORK -

Please tell us Ohians concerned about the Tusc Valley and other groundwater aquifers, plus massive water usage from our Lake Erie and streams being increased for industry....WHY are our people LESS deserving of protections by such bans regarding our own watersheds here?

Please copy & Paste You Tube James Northrup / Former Gas & Oil Industry
http://youtu.be/M2Ozcl7lV_g

Philip F. Sweet
gardona12.1@verizon.net / Gbfa/mpfa

PHILIP F. SWEET, BUFFALO, NY on Mon Jul 4, 2011 at 08:17 AM

While the certainty of huge profits here for a small handful cannot be denied their lobbyists and spin machine are working overtime to frack doubt on the environmental and health disasters associated with fracking. When was the last time Dick Cheney was involved in anything that put people ahead of profits and how comfortable are we in any venture where Halliburton is involved as a major player and they refuse to disclose the ingredients of their non biodegradable toxic cocktail they're using to reap huge profits ? So we'll blunder on ahead posioning water tables and injecting carcinogens into the soil and when these rural areas become the spawning ground for sick and deformed babies the profiteers will be long gone and their lawyers will send a card saying sorry, see you in court, we really had no idea...I'm about ready for a bible quote at this stage.I agree with Brother Fries from Fredonia, we really need to make this as difficult as we can for these motherfrackers.

SEAN CROWLEY, EDEN, NY on Sun Jul 3, 2011 at 09:38 AM

Money talks.

Another sickening example of privatized profit through socialized risk. Disgusting!

This benefits no one other than the frackers and their political croonies.

What a bunch of BS.

JIM COFFED, DEPEW, NY on Fri Jul 1, 2011 at 12:01 PM

Our aquifers are more valuable than gold. Literally. Governor Cuomo gained a lot of political capital with his support of gay marriage. Now, with his support of hydrofracking and the polluting of ground water, he's lost it.

BOB CATALANO, DERBY, NY on Fri Jul 1, 2011 at 10:03 AM

If you can afford a lobbyisty you can have whatever you want. Its NEVER about the good of the people...just the corporation.

MICHAEL SANTORO, BUFFALO, NY on Fri Jul 1, 2011 at 09:44 AM

Toxic in Tonawanda

Industry officials have stressed that tens of thousands of vertical natural gas wells have been drilled safely throughout New York, and most of those drilled in the last three decades or so have been hydraulically fractured.

Say What!

Question?

Where will Frackers obtain the millions, upon millions, upon millions of gallons of irreplaceable potable water now contaminated, now destroyed forever that will have to be sent to landfills, seriously contaminated with radiation and dangerous chemicals?

Where are the landfills that will accept this hazardous waste?

Will this ill founded insane expanded endeavor become a further burden to the taxpayer?

For shame!, democrats have silently stood by as the republican Cheney/Bush loophole promoting "FRACKING", has caused already irrepairable damage to our environment, health and quality of life and clearly violates the clean water act.

Hon. Andrew M. Cuomo as our newly elected Gov. State of New York needs to step forward and either endorse or condemn this outrageous further attempt by government and republican corporate interest to totally destroy our precious water resources and place health burdens upon our communities.

New York's moratorium on "FRACKING" needs to be permanently made law and if needed a public referendum should be seriously considered.

Must see video:Please copy & paste James Northrup speaks out..... http://youtu.be/M2Ozcl7lV_g

Philip F. Sweet
gardona12.1@verizon.net
Gbfa/mpfa





PHILIP F. SWEET, BUFFALO, NY on Fri Jul 1, 2011 at 09:04 AM

If fracking was safe then why did they did they lobby for an exemption from the Clean Water Act, signed in 1972 by Richard Nixon, in order to obtain drilling permits? A sad day for New York State and clean drinking water.

JEFFREY POMIETLARZ, CHEEKTOWAGA, NY on Fri Jul 1, 2011 at 08:05 AM

They are not going to drill around the Syracuse and NYC watershed areas. I guess their water is more important.

LOUIS MARINACCIO, BUFFALO, NY on Fri Jul 1, 2011 at 08:04 AM

The basis for the DEC proposal to prohibit drilling in the NY City and Syracuse watersheds is that possible pollution associated with drilling and fracking would taint the drinking water of the many millions of people living downstream in NY City.

But all NY state residents live in watersheds! According to the DEC, there are 17 watersheds across the state. And we all live downstream of possible pollution.

What's good for NY City and Syracuse watersheds should apply to all of our watersheds. All NY state residents deserve the same level of protection from water pollution that can harm people as well as the plants and animals on our farms and in the wild. Water is life.

If shale-gas drilling is a threat to NY City water, it is a threat to the water of all NY state residents. If drilling is prohibited in one NY watershed, it must be prohibited in all watersheds.

DAVID KOWALSKI, SNYDER, NY on Fri Jul 1, 2011 at 07:57 AM

1 2
Add your comment

The Feed / What’s Happening Now

Latest Updates
Most Commented
Most Viewed
City & Region

NATIVE AMERICANS OUTRAGED BY RAID

Sabres & NHL

Sabres' first year under Pegula a qualified success

City & Region

Mail-processing center closing will slow delivery

Amherst

UB dorm robbery report rings false; three charged

Courts

Corasanti's attorneys argue for dismissal

Bills & NFL

Bills restructure McGee's contract

Erie County

Holding Center incident: Fair force, or foul?

Southern Tier

Hunting death ruled 'tragic' but not crime

Rod Watson

Parents, too, are in need of evaluations

Niagara Falls

New company to run Maid of the Mist in Canada

Newsroom Tips

Have a news tip you think The Buffalo News should investigate?

Call The News tip line at 849-4475 or email us at investigations@buffnews.com.

All calls and emails will be kept confidential.

Buffalo Marketplace

Marketplace videos

Watch the latest offers, products and services from our advertisers.

Browse our print ads

It's the ultimate advantage for Buffalo consumers. Never miss another ad again!

Buffalo Savers: coupons

Buffalo coupons at your fingertips.
Just click and print. It's Easy!

close

Browse our print adsclose

Special Sections

Buffalo Saversclose

Local coupons

Featured coupon

Latest Blogs

Sports, Ink

This Day in Buffalo Sports History: Beef in the middle

Hungry for More

Ethiopian restaurant reported opening in Black Rock

BillBoard

Chan on Merriman & Brad

Strictly Business

New York Works Youth Program

Gusto

The tavern turns over