Buffalo’s rabid Goo Goo Dolls fan base just wasn’t enough as superstar Justin Timberlake took down the hometown favorites to advance to the finals of Gusto’s Summer Madness.

The Erie County Fair, going strong for 175 years, breezed by Shakespeare in Delaware Park to take the other spot in the finals.

Timberlake and the Fair are now going head-to-head on with polls closing at noon on June 9. The winner will be announced in Gusto on June 10.