Skip to Main Navigation

The Buffalo News

Web Search
by YAHOO! SEARCH

Kenmore

Basketball players suspended for N-word

Ken East girls used it in pregame chant

News Staff Reporter

Published:December 8, 2011, 4:17 PM

Font Size:
  • E-mail
  • Share
  • Print

Related photos

More photos

Related links

Updated: December 9, 2011, 1:14 PM

At least a dozen Kenmore East High School girls varsity basketball players have been suspended and face other sanctions for using a racial slur as part of their regular pregame locker room chant. The practice apparently had been going on for years.

Teammates would hold hands before their games, say a prayer together, then yell "One, two, three [N-word]!" before running out onto the court, according to offended students.

The team's only African-American player this year, sophomore Tyra Batts, said she was shocked when she learned of the tradition before the team's opening game against Sweet Home High School last Friday.

"I said, 'You're not allowed to say that word because I don't like that word,'" she recalled. "They said, 'You know we're not racist, Tyra. It's just a word, not a label.' I was outnumbered."

Mark P. Mondanaro, superintendent of the Kenmore-Town of Tonawanda School District, said no coaches, administrators or other adults with the school were aware of the "psych-up tradition" until Tyra was suspended for getting into a fight with another player over the use of racial slurs during practice and before games. "The minute an adult knew, we started our inquiry and investigation," Mondanaro said Thursday.

The girls apparently used their brief, private locker room time to say the chant after coaches and other adults had left.

A number of Kenmore East students said there's been a lot of racial tension at the high school since Tyra was suspended after attacking another student at school Monday. The female varsity basketball players have found themselves being ostracized and harassed, and chatter on social networking sites like Facebook reportedly has been filled with angry comments back and forth between white and minority students.

Tyra, 15, said that before the Sweet Home game, she argued with other players about the chant, but virtually no one took her side. "They said it's a tradition; they do it every year," she said.

During a later practice scrimmage game, she said she and another teammate exchanged words over some physical roughness on the court. Tyra said she "said something dumb," after which her teammate called her "a black piece of [expletive]." Then on Monday, she said, she saw the girl in school, threw her into a locker, choked and punched her. "It was a buildup of anger and frustration at being singled out of the whole team," she said.

Both girls were suspended for fighting.

Tyra added that her teammates would routinely make racial references and jokes during practice, including ones regarding slavery, shackles and "picking cotton." She said her coach, Kristy Bondgren, heard comments from other players about Tyra being black but was unaware of the pregame chant.

Bondgren did not a return a call to her cellphone seeking comment. Mondanaro said he is handling all media questions regarding this matter on behalf of the district.

Mondanaro said he personally apologized to Tyra, whom he declined to identify by name, and apologized to her parents as well. Kenmore East Principal Patrick Heyden also apologized.

As a result of the district's investigation, in which it was determined the basketball players violated both the school's conduct code and the extracurricular athletic code, Mondanaro announced the following disciplinary measures:

  • All Kenmore East High School varsity girls basketball team practices have been suspended through the rest of this week.
  • Saturday's scheduled game against Olean has been postponed.
  • The related team field trip to St. Bonaventure University has been canceled.
  • The student athletes will all serve a one-game suspension by the end of the season, at games to be determined at a later date. It's not expected that the girls would all be suspended for the same game, which would result in a forfeited game.
  • Mondanaro is voluntarily rescinding last year's Niagara Frontier League Sportsmanship Award for the entire school.
  • Students who engaged in the chant will receive a two-day, out-of-school suspension.
  • The student athletes will be required to participate in cultural sensitivity training, which is being arranged through an outside agency.

Members of the Batts family said they appreciated the district's swift response but would have been happier to see harsher consequences, including a week's suspension for the students and the forfeiture of the team's entire season.

"This wasn't something that just developed this year," said Raymond Batts Jr., Tyra's father. "This is something that's been ongoing for quite some time."

Mondanaro responded that the district chose not to forfeit the team's entire season because that would also punish Tyra, who is a member of the team. There also would be negative ramifications for the other schools the girls play, he said.

Tyra said she would be willing to play at the lower junior varsity level for another year and wonders if it's possible for the team to continue under these circumstances. It would be awkward for her to continue playing with the team right now, she said, and she's concerned about teammates going up against other teams with more black players.

"It just wouldn't be safe," she said. "There would be a lot of conflict going on."

She also said only two of her teammates have apologized to her for their behavior.

Tyra initially faced the possibility of a long-term suspension for engaging in a fight at school, but she said it was later reduced to a straight five-day suspension that ends today after the circumstances of the fight became clear.

Raymond Batts said he thinks that's an appropriate punishment for his daughter, given the circumstances.

During his news conference Thursday, Mondanaro said, "The insensitive chant is absolutely unacceptable, insensitive and not representative of the diverse student body within the ... School District."

He said what the basketball players did is "wrong, unacceptable, unfortunate and will never, ever be tolerated" and hopes this type of behavior is not reflective of a larger problem involving racism in the district.

stan@buffnews.comnull

true

Comments

Sort:NEWEST FIRST | OLDEST FIRST

ok first ..... the tradition is stupid and uncalled for.
second...violence is not the way to solve any issue. Violence is a seperate issue and need punishment. We have been trying to police racism for decades. Every little word
has to be adressed buy the indavidual them self. The one for saying it, and the one so sensative that they go to the news over it ( because they reacted wrong and punishment insued).
third ... check this poor victoms face book, email, tagged, tweets, I bet she is ussing it allot. But her excuse will be it means something different. BLAH BLAH BLAH.
Either the word is bad or its not... just quit using it. Even as slang (good or bad) set's a bad presidence.
Question? Why did she not go to the news before she turned violent and effected her future?
Why did she go to news only after she was punished?
Why doe's she think people will side with violence?
I didn't hear one appology the the girl she started fighting with? Just excuses?
Why did her parents not go the the news at first sound of chant before game?
Parents get involved in your childs life.. thats why we are the parent and they are the child.. To show the how and when to choose your battle properly.

JOE PRICE, PLANO, TX on Sun Dec 11, 2011 at 10:32 AM

Any school should build good people and good character through the use of education and responsible policy (I know, this is not a perfect world). Will some good kid's think in a way that does not comply, will their parents proclaim their young adults actions are false, untrue misconstrued? Yes they will. Do I believe that the young woman who reported the chant told the truth about the additional slander on the court because she reasoned that the chant and the on-court behavior went hand-in-hand? Sure I do. Do I think that the person's who spoke the chant know that it was derogatory? Yes I do. If this was investigated and members from other teams they played (all members) were questioned in a one-on-one session; I bet you would have a few students from all camps confirm the on court comments. I would also bet that if the refs were questioned and allowed strict confidentiality to be candid then, someone would confirm something they overheard. Now there will be those of you that will say the above thoughts are all speculation, an irrational lunatic rant. In retort I would say, a school system official stated "...this type of behavior is not reflective of a larger problem involving racism in the district." Obviously, this official is aware of outside conditions and did not think to reason that these issues on the outside would overlap their school environments? Hmmm, and therefore; shouldn't the administration have had some interview process to detect potential overlaps? Some confidential reporting system so any staff member could make claims and be shielded from colleague scrutiny? At least, some system would have allowed his office to privetly investigate, attempt some resolution to fact's discovered and improve policy.

MARK PIAZZA, DORCHESTER, MA on Sat Dec 10, 2011 at 04:49 PM

[I'm not asking those girls to bear the weight of history, I'm just asking them to stop repeating it.]

Very well said Carmen but I'm not certain what 'spirit' the other remarks were made in. It was not reported and I'd rather not read anything into it for good or bad. Teammates trade many 'barbs' with each other in competitive play (usually, not very polite) and we have no reason to make any assumptions that they were racially motivated. Only Tyla would really know what spirit they were made in.

While you may not be asking these girls to bear the weight of history on this many of the respondants (from all over the country) to this thread are doing that by disregarding the actual facts of what happened to make their own points. I can't blame people for choosing an issue to put forward their own opinions on things they deem important even if the issue isn't an exact fit. But you can see what happens when an issue like this goes viral you get klansman from Indiana using the incident to springboard their own issues about reverse discrimination, etc. and why shouldn't they if the discussion isn't really tied to the actual facts of the incident?

RICK BRIDENBAKER, WEST SENECA, NY on Sat Dec 10, 2011 at 04:16 PM

[Tyra added that her teammates would routinely make racial references and jokes during practice, including ones regarding slavery, shackles and "picking cotton."]

The chant can be misconstrued, but the jokes are not part of the spirit of friendship or camaraderie. She asked them to stop and they refused. That is not friendship, it's bullying.

I'm not asking those girls to bear the weight of history, I'm just asking them to stop repeating it.

CARMEN BARTOLOTTA, BUFFALO, NY on Sat Dec 10, 2011 at 03:41 PM

Springboard to larger issues? Really? The facts here are different then writers and so called music creativity that look for an instigation device to make money. Those areas fit the If you do not like it leave; do not buy, etc... The fight, though unfortunate, should not have had to occur or become a last resort personal judgment for this young woman. The school should have immediately stopped the so called Tradition when notified it existed. Then the team should have been assembled and spoken to as adults and informed that the practice was and is inappropriate (to say the least) and, why such a word choice is not a description of unity but, a word that is a description of separation (again, to say the least). They should have defused the situation and asserted the inappropriate poetic license in a school that serves the values of a community and nation, in this case, has been misused. The leadership (coach and principal) should have defused any thinking by others that this young woman caused or committed any wrongdoing; thanked her for bringing the matter to their attention, and thanked the team for their understanding and cooperation. They should have offered an opportunity for any of the team to speak to the principal one on one, in private if they would like to discuss anything further assuring confidentiality. This MAY have smoothed some things over, removed the problem, reduced the backlash sustained by the young woman who made the complaint and possibly, keep the team a team. Least of all, a proper dealing of this situation may have removed all the punishments and suspensions that have occurred as well as others who will in some warped way, hold this young women responsible for all that has occurred.

MARK PIAZZA, DORCHESTER, MA on Sat Dec 10, 2011 at 03:14 PM

Hmmmm...that chip on your shoulder whispers in your ear that you're exempt from accountability? Ain't dat par for the course...

RICK HUTCHINSON, BUFFALO, NY on Sat Dec 10, 2011 at 01:41 PM

Carmen,
[It's not having an ax to grind when one notes that this many in this country use tradition to trump the question of intolerance and lack of respect for people in minority groups.]

That's fair enough and I can understand why people use any incident like this to springboard a larger agenda. But there is some harm when these same people think it's ok to disregard the actual facts of the matter to do so. Not only do you victimize the truth but you victimize real human beings in the process too because they are made to bear the consequences not only of their own actions but of the 'bigger' agenda and all its history as well.

This 'tradition' was started as a private joke between a black athelete and a white one. It doesn't take a leap of imagination to assume that this was done in a spirit of friendship or at least comraderie. That this grew into a tradition whose consequences now make it look like a rather stupid one is probably something that both of these originators regret.

You are not free however to completely ignore these actual facts to turn this incident into some kind of 'Jena' unless you are completely in agreement with others who will choose to do the same thing to further their own agendas - for good or bad. You are not even free to disregard these facts to bring an intelligent discussion on the issues of race that still plague this society if the actual truth of the matter is going to be thrown out as the price.

This willful and knowing loss of perspective is more disturbing than the issue itself.

RICK BRIDENBAKER, WEST SENECA, NY on Sat Dec 10, 2011 at 01:35 PM

The only thing we are legally responsible for is obeying the laws of our nation and respecting the rights of others. There is no excuse and no getting around those responsibilities. Obey the laws and respect the rights of others; I do not need to qualify that.





CARMEN BARTOLOTTA, BUFFALO, NY on Sat Dec 10, 2011 at 01:31 PM

@ Carmen

"White guilt" is just so cowardly,you know?

RICK HUTCHINSON, BUFFALO, NY on Sat Dec 10, 2011 at 01:14 PM

@ Carmen

Per your last comment,qualify it with an explanation as to why I'm responsible for "four hundred years of slavery and oppression" ( claimed by blacks) . "Four hundred years",interesting;copied from the Bible no less.

RICK HUTCHINSON, BUFFALO, NY on Sat Dec 10, 2011 at 01:10 PM

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Add your comment

The Feed / What’s Happening Now

Latest Updates
Most Commented
Most Viewed
City of Buffalo

Ex-Bill Losman selling his Oakland Place home

Sabres & NHL

Sabres, Roy making their points

Courts

Corasanti's attorneys argue for dismissal

Lancaster

Lancaster union chief blasts head of NYSUT

Erie County

Sheriff's takeover of transit police eyed

Bucky Gleason

Boyes tries old routine to end slump

West Seneca

Couple lauded for a lifetime of love

Cheektowaga

Arrest made in Watkins' shooting death

Sabres & NHL

Miller remains sharp between the pipes

Niagara Falls

New company to run Maid of the Mist in Canada

Newsroom Tips

Have a news tip you think The Buffalo News should investigate?

Call The News tip line at 849-4475 or email us at investigations@buffnews.com.

All calls and emails will be kept confidential.

Buffalo Marketplace

Marketplace videos

Watch the latest offers, products and services from our advertisers.

Browse our print ads

It's the ultimate advantage for Buffalo consumers. Never miss another ad again!

Buffalo Savers: coupons

Buffalo coupons at your fingertips.
Just click and print. It's Easy!

close

Browse our print adsclose

Special Sections

Buffalo Saversclose

Local coupons

Featured coupon

Latest Blogs

Sports, Ink

This Day in Buffalo Sports History: The Boogie Man

SulliView

Reporter Marie Colvin died heroically, staying 'one more day' in a Syria under siege

BillBoard

'Mouse' McNally hired as Bengals consultant

Campus Watch

Ohio-UB live blog

Gusto

Remembering actor Neil Garvey