Skip to Main Navigation

The Buffalo News

Web Search
by YAHOO! SEARCH

Jail inmate jumps to his death

News Niagara Reporter

Published:January 23, 2012, 12:15 PM

Font Size:
  • E-mail
  • Share
  • Print

Updated: January 24, 2012, 8:11 AM

LOCKPORT — A Hartland man with a history of alcohol problems and mental health issues committed suicide Monday morning in the Niagara County Jail, according to several law enforcement sources.

Harold G. Case, 50, of Carmen Road, who was recently sentenced to 15 years in state prison for attempted rape, was identified as the victim.

Sheriff James R. Voutour would not immediately confirm the victim’s name but did say the inmate killed himself by jumping from a second-floor walkway just after 6 a. m. as he was being transfered to state prison. He also said a suicide note was found.

“In the pods [that house inmates] there is an upper level and a lower level, it’s two stories,” Voutour said. “The upper level has a walkway in front of it with a railing. When he came out of his cell to head to his van to go to state prison, he climbed up on that railing and jumped.”

Deputies were unable to stop him, Voutour said.

Case jumped headfirst and died at the scene from head injuries, law enforcement sources said.

Voutour said this was the first suicide at the jail since early 2009. He noted that all inmates are screened before they come into the jail and that Case was deemed a low risk for suicide.

“Things just happen. Today he was going to state prison for 15 years, and he obviously didn’t want to do that,” Voutour said.

Case was sentenced to the prison term Jan. 5 in Niagara County Court, plus 15 years post-release supervision, for sexually assaulting a woman March 25, 2011, in her Lockport home.

The sentence on a reduced charge of attempted rape was the stiffest sentence that could have been imposed by Judge Matthew J. Murphy III, who called the attack “a violent, brutal, premeditated sexual assault.”

The victim, who knew Case, was threatened with a knife, which left a mark on her throat, Assistant District Attorney ElizabethR. Donatello told the court.

On another occasion, the victim said, Case drove past her workplace and made a gesture as if he was going to shoot her, then tried to persuade her not to press charges.

Case admitted in court at his sentencing, “I did get out of hand. The knife was just to scare her because I thought I was going to lose her. I was pretty sure there was another fellow.”

Case’s attorney, George V. C. Muscato, told the court on Jan. 5 that his client has a history of alcohol problems and mental health issues.

“If this weren’t a violent crime, some sort of treatment would be appropriate,” Muscato said.

Muscato declined to comment on his client’s suicide, but told The News, “I feel very badly for his family.”

Voutour said an investigation will be conducted to make sure deputies followed all procedures.

“So far we did,” Voutour said of preliminary investigation. “If we can find any place to improve, obviously we would do that. I don’t see anything that anybody did wrong at this point.”

nfischer@buffnews.comnull

true

Comments

Sort:NEWEST FIRST | OLDEST FIRST

It saddens me to hear how brutal people are about others with mental health issues. I don't agree what so ever about what George did to his girlfriend, but it is clear that he needed help. People who never experience what it is like to live with a mental illness should not be allowed to pass judgement, till they spend just one day in someones shoes that suffers. The people who are left untreated are more likely the ones who tend to lean towards more serious crimes. The whole 12 years i knew George, i would have never seen this coming. I wish the help was there for him but the whole time through his employment with his last employer, their medical insurance did not cover mental health. And then, after almost 30 years with his employer, the plant closed and he lost his job. Not to be mistaken as to making excuses for him, but people need to open their eyes to others around them and help others who need it. Its actually sad that someone who wanted to be loved so badly, would go to such an extreme to hurt the one he loved. Thats what is wrong with society, we are so eager to pass judgement before we even know the facts. If there was more help for people who suffer from a mental illness, then we would reduce the 68% of our prison systems who are mentally ill and would not have to blame them for our tax dollars. R.I.P George, I am sure you are in a better place. Away from this cruel world and all that inhabit it. As for his Victim, I am so sorry that you became a victim of Georges neglect and what happen to you, I would not wish what happen to you on anyone. He wasn't a bad person, he was just really sick.

HOLLIE R. PIPILES, NEWFANE, NY on Mon Jan 30, 2012 at 02:57 PM

I've heard that rapist child molesters and criminals of that nature are frowned upon in prison. When Karma comes back to you your considered the victim you die by the sword you lived by.
The focus should be on the condition of the victim, he's been on the low road. I mean the lowest 6ft under good she can turn that negative into a positive and take the Higher one and never worry about seeing him again.

TRINITA ELLIS, BUFFALO, NY on Wed Jan 25, 2012 at 12:20 AM

Harold, its quite clear from your ignorant post that you have NO idea what you are talking about. Inmates at Erie County Holding center are awaiting trials for their crimes. The ones that have killed themselves are usually the ones who have had prior attempts and mental issues. If they put every inmate on a one-on-one special watch, your tax dollars would double. Just about every person who goes into the system has mental issues, thats why most commit crimes. The only inmates who do not need this type of treatment are the ones who have done previous bids in prison before. We have people who have done 5-6 bids that are constantly in and out of the system. The problem here is that we are not locking these people away long enough. Rape someone and you get 2-4 years, driving drunk often gets you a longer sentence.

Lets fix whats broken, and not waste needless tax dollars. I think he just saved State Tax payers 34,000 a year for the next 15 years.

DONALD LOCKWOOD, DERBY, NY on Tue Jan 24, 2012 at 08:26 PM

Think of the money saved if 1 out of 3 followed!!!

RICK HESS, LAS VEGAS, NV on Tue Jan 24, 2012 at 10:49 AM

Harold, future inmates can stay at your house. You can just keep an eye on them for us.

JEFFREY BRZYSKI, TONAWANDA, on Tue Jan 24, 2012 at 08:57 AM

I could say, well he will never again try to rape someone. He saved the taxpayers some money. But lets look at the convicted. He had a history of alcohol abuse plus mental problems. I dont understand why the jail did not take extra precautions with such an inmate. Regardless of how crazy he was, he knew his life was for all intent over. 15 yrs. prison at age 50? That is a death sentence. Hopefully the jail learned something from this incident. People still in County custody after sentencing, especially if they were handed down a stiff sentence, should be deemed suicidal, regardless if they show any signs, or not. Isnt that the same problem we are having in Erie Country? Once a defendant has been sentenced to a long term of incarceration and he is back in his cell again and has time to think, no doubt, depression will set in. It is at this time when he needs to me monitored. He should have never been taken back to his pod, awaiting Stet transportation. He should have been housed in a segregation unit and be cuffed at all times when he moves out of his cell. An individual like him will not only hurt himself, but also others. Why not, in his eyes, his life is over. Once he is in a State facility things will change for him as he is surrounded by many others who are also doing long sentences, many even longer then his.

HAROLD HAHN, BUFFALO, NY on Mon Jan 23, 2012 at 07:31 PM

Voutour will comment later this afternoon....

...no doubt after consulting with the acknowledged expert in the field...

...Tim Howard.

JACK SAVIOLA, BUFFALO, NY on Mon Jan 23, 2012 at 01:46 PM

Must be Chris Collins' fault.

SAL MACALUSO, ORCHARD PARK, NY on Mon Jan 23, 2012 at 12:54 PM

Add your comment

The Feed / What’s Happening Now

Latest Updates
Most Commented
Most Viewed
Sabres & NHL

Sabres, Miller jump for Roy in shootout

Bills & NFL

Bills need to take step, but won't reach

Sabres & NHL

Sabres let a point slip away in overtime

Bucky Gleason

Five-point gap in race more than a stretch

Bills & NFL

Progress made in talks with Johnson

Southern Tier

Accusation of crack pipe in bra leads to new charge

Niagara Falls

Falls man charged in rape of girl, 14

Margaret Sullivan

Okun steps away from the table

Weather

High winds drop trees, but snow stays behind

North Buffalo/Hertel

Zoo opens doors to protect a rare breed

Newsroom Tips

Have a news tip you think The Buffalo News should investigate?

Call The News tip line at 849-4475 or email us at investigations@buffnews.com.

All calls and emails will be kept confidential.

Buffalo Marketplace

Marketplace videos

Watch the latest offers, products and services from our advertisers.

Browse our print ads

It's the ultimate advantage for Buffalo consumers. Never miss another ad again!

Buffalo Savers: coupons

Buffalo coupons at your fingertips.
Just click and print. It's Easy!

close

Browse our print adsclose

Special Sections

Buffalo Saversclose

Local coupons

Featured coupon

Latest Blogs

Politics Now

Five Questions with David Rivera

Gusto

Church sounds: David Wasik celebrates music in St. Thomas Aquinas Church

Sports, Ink

This Day in Buffalo Sports History: One nice night

Prep Talk

Dunkirk forward punched by East player

Sabres Edge

Vote for your three stars