Skip to Main Navigation

The Buffalo News

Web Search
by YAHOO! SEARCH

COMMENTARY

St. Augustine proves what a school can be

News Columnist

Published:July 7, 2011, 12:00 AM

Font Size:
  • E-mail
  • Share
  • Print

Recent Rod Watson Columns

Updated: July 7, 2011, 2:40 PM

The young men in tuxedos defied all of the stereotypes — including the one about whether they can learn.

Coming from low-income homes in gang-infested parts of a poor city, they are going places you might not expect: St. Joseph’s Collegiate Institute, Canisius, Cardinal O’Hara and similar top-shelf high schools.

All 25 graduates of the St. Augustine Campus of Nativity Miguel Middle School, in the Kensington-Bailey area, will attend private, Catholic or charter high schools this fall.

The boys — there’s a separate school for girls — weren’t always on that path.

One by one, the student speakers at the school’s graduation ceremony decribed the transformation they underwent in an atmosphere of discipline, long hours — even Saturdays — and caring on the part of nuns and lay teachers committed to students’ success.

Joshua Huffman talked about improving his manners, his sense of self-respect “and the way I dress and speak.” Ken Ngoopos learned to avoid street temptations and be “strong enough to walk away.” Jacob Crawl was converted from a kid “with a horrible temper and unpleasant attitude” into one who raised his GPA by 18 points.

What are the school’s secrets? There aren’t any. The formula — small classes, committed teachers, involved parents — is well-known.

“We have to keep classes small because one of the keys is that all of our teachers know all of our students very well,” school President Nancy Langer said.

Knowing your students also means knowing what they’re going through outside of school, such as what 14-year-old Jordan Williams went through last Halloween when a stray bullet pierced a Bickford Avenue home and lodged near the spine of his 13-year-old friend.

He stayed with the girl until the ambulance came. It was the type of trauma that can derail the best-laid plans.

“I overcame it, and I got my head back on track,” said Jordan, who’s on his way to St. Mary’s High School in Lancaster.

He credits St. Augustine with challenging him and putting him on “the right path,” unlike the charter school he previously attended.

“It was really just, ‘Teach ’em and get ’em out of here,’ ” Jordan says, contrasting that with the staff’s commitment at St. Augustine. “This is very different.”

That’s not by accident. “The main thing is the relationship

that’s developed between the student, the school and the families,” Langer said. “So it’s like a three-way partnership.”

But if you’re expecting a strong PTA, you’d be wrong. The school doesn’t have one because many parents work multiple jobs. Instead, it simply requires parents to be available and responsive and, conversely, to contact the school if they have a concern. Langer said parents are constantly in and out of the school.

St. Augustine is selective — which public schools can’t be — but not in the way you’d think. Applicants attend a summer school and overnight camp where the school assesses not test scores, but attitude and a desire to change.

It looks for kids “who don’t do well on state tests,” Langer said, and judges itself on which high schools they get into and how well they do. Last year, she said, 84 percent of alumni graduated from high school — a figure all the more impressive when considering St. Augustine’s demographic profile.

It’s what happens when teaching is a mission, not a job; when parents become educational partners; and when bureaucracy doesn’t get in the way of lengthening the school day or school week, or doing anything else that works.

Is it replicable in a large public school district? Maybe not.

But it does prove one thing: The kids are not the problem.

rwatson@buffnews.comnull

true

Comments

Sort:NEWEST FIRST | OLDEST FIRST

I see where Mr. crowley's frustration comes from. It seems like a theme in local media today to pin parents vs teacher's. Too many are buying into it and more often than not it's suburban people who have nothing to do with the district commenting.

Now on the point of the article..

I don't know much about this program but I do think a school being able to teach children morality and ethics is an advantage that private schools have that public and charters don't. Also a smaller setting, not just in the classroom but the school in general, gives the chance for students to know their fellow students and most of the staff. Also parents tend to be more involved, in part because of the financle investement or if they are receiving aide they usually volunteer with the school.

Basically you can't compare private schools to public schools, especially religious schools. It's like comparing apples and oranges..

LAURA THIEL, BUFFALO, NY on Sat Jul 9, 2011 at 10:51 AM

What the St. Augustine school proves is that a school can achieve high results when it carefully selects 52 students who are taught by six teachers, including a Catholic priest and a Catholic Charities volunteer.

An eight and a half hour school day, mandatory summer leadership program, and small classes without the usual drama found in many city schools provides a perfect setting for learning.

Tuition at St. Augustine is $2,400. Most students pay only $500. Paying for education, even a small amount, is also a great motivator.


MICHALE SZYMANSKI, ORCHARD PARK, NY on Fri Jul 8, 2011 at 12:30 PM

Good article Rod, St. Augustine's is a great school with caring compassionate people.

I don't understand the negativity in some of the comments that are posted after you report about a Bright Spot in our community.

In our Youth Center we have a rule:

"Positive words only are spoken because
negative words make people feel broken."

Go do something nice for somebody.
Thanks for your time.

Bob Kuebler

BOB KUEBLER, BUFFALO, NY on Fri Jul 8, 2011 at 06:52 AM

here is what Rod Watson wrote :

St. Augustine is selective which public schools cant be but not in the way youd think. Applicants attend a summer school and overnight camp where the school assesses not test scores, but attitude and a desire to change.
This my friend as much as you dont like it, is screeening. I am far from retired and maybe you should do your job instead of writing emails on company time if you are at work.

It looks for kids who dont do well on state tests, Langer said, and judges itself on which high schools they get into and how well they do. Last year, she said, 84 percent of alumni graduated from high school a figure all the more impressive when considering St. Augustines demographic profile.

These kids also attend a summer camp and a sleepover before a decision is made ? No Buffalo School can say "Sorry, we dont like your attitude, go to a charter." As benign as you think it may be its screening and its an option not available to Buffalo Public Schools in their mission.

God Bless St Augustines and all of their kids faculty and staff. It appears to be a noble and sincere enterprise. It can also receive praise without the usual equal and opposite contumely Mr. Watson seems obliged to heap on Buffalo Schools, as if he has all the ideas. You sir enjoy your fifteen minutes and please read whats on the page not what your suburban enlightenment tells you should be on the page. You didnt invent caring about people who struggle and you have lots to learn. The last word is all yours. Gotta run, I am marching up front with Chris Collins at the Carl for Mayor parade.

SEAN CROWLEY, EDEN, NY on Thu Jul 7, 2011 at 09:10 PM

i'm at work, and i was in a hurry. so i'm not taking, the time 2 spell. this stuff you, say, about the screening, couldn't be more wrong. i, am not a teacher(so 2 speak) if i was retired i would, have more time 2 spell, check why, don't go, to the school, and see what its like before you comment

MARK KRAMER, WILLIAMSVILLE, NY on Thu Jul 7, 2011 at 08:42 PM

You cant get over yourself and you cant believe anyone but you cares about poor kids in the hood. Spare me, this is the soft headed tripe that makes liberals the butt of everyone elses jokes. I never expect this guy to praise public school teachers nor did I ask him to. Your dibls scores must be improving but you still cant comprehend very well. I never took anything away from the place or its people. I did observe based on what your patron wrote that you do screen these kids pretty well. Read the article its in there. Watson never says anything good about one group unless he can backhand another. Did you read his piece about the afro educator who has books to sell and wants more black teachers? Well his spiel wasnt the focus of the article, the focus was Watson asking why all the white teachers from Buffalo didnt flock to the thing to hear themselves marginalized by a guy with an obvious agenda. Rod cant just praise St Augustines without moaning that everyone else just has a job while the teachers there are on a mission. Your defensiveness is understandable as is your rookie tizzy to send me back to the shadows of bad teachers while you bask in Rod Watsons glory. Knock yourself out friend but understand what I said and didnt say. Why dont you go look up the article about Chris Collins at the parade and read what I said about him as long as you know how I feel about the guy. And can you get a spellcheck before you mentor and teach those kids any more ? You know everything all ready theres no teaching you. Good luck. p.s. Race baiting is a fine art and you there yet but eventually you may get to be a masterbaiter some day.

SEAN CROWLEY, EDEN, NY on Thu Jul 7, 2011 at 07:20 PM

First of all, Williamsville, is a mailing address! 2nd you have been to 2 many Carl Pallodino rallies. You also, don't know anything, about me, or the school your talking about. you don't know how they get their, students, or anything else. Also you are complaining that Mr. watson, didn't praise, public school teacher. in an article, about a private. school. i think i know what u don't like about, Rod Watson, and its, not he writing. You should be complaining about, your County executive, that has not spent, a penney, on the city of Buffalo. I'm just glad, the kids i cpach, and the kids i mentor, are learning, frpm the teachers, at St. Augistines! thay could be learnig from a bitter man like u

MARK KRAMER, WILLIAMSVILLE, NY on Thu Jul 7, 2011 at 04:34 PM

ok junior i'll stick to farming and you can stick to rolling around williamsville with your izod collar flipped listening to soulful indie music in your daddy's Saab. did you miss the part where i said god bless your boss and these kids ? maybe your own reading comprehension could use a little tune up. i agreed that the thing is a great opportunity and as far as being negative I asked why rod watson cant say something nice without backhanding teachers who dont happen to work in st augustine. my first 6 yrs teaching were spent at Ken High and Burgard so save me your hard luck from the hood stories that dazzle everyone in williamsville I have my own. your failure to read any nuance in my comments is representative of your own ignorance and your own assumption that only you care and only you help kids. there are a lot of people on a mission not just you and rod watson in spite of what he says. two weeks ago he was bemoaning white teachers for. not attending an afro centric speakers talk where he asks for more black teachers. farm that.

SEAN CROWLEY, EDEN, NY on Thu Jul 7, 2011 at 01:56 PM

I think, Seans comment, is ignorant! I for one, am familiar, with, St. Augistines, and the great work, they do. Since i am the one that called you, and asked you, to do the article, i am insulted. Maybe, sean should stick to farming. He obviously knows nothing, about the inner city. I witnessed, the turn around, in Jordan"s life. this, city, needs more schools, like St Augistines. People, always look, for something negative to say. It is a great program, with a huge success ratio

MARK KRAMER, WILLIAMSVILLE, NY on Thu Jul 7, 2011 at 11:39 AM

When did anyone ever accuse the kids of being the problem Rod ? Your thesis' killshot takes down a strawman of your own creation. Did Phil Rumore say somewhere that the kids are the problem ? Did James Williams say that ? No and no, you said it because you essentially ran out of story when you had to admit that this only works in miniature and with vigorously screened students as these kids all were before they were allowed into the program. The same rhetoricians who love to say Run Ed. like a business always forget this little caveat, the one that says businesses can pick and choose whom they get their materials from and at what price. Public schools have no such perk; we accept the public whether they are Hutch Tech or East Ferry Detention material and there's no way around it. As for your same old assertion that teaching is only a job to everyone except those who toil in some desperately underfunded program working for peanuts with no job security is an insult to teachers from Futures Academy to Nardin. Speaking of which, isn't it also a little ironic that you are using these kids' admission into private high schools as the slam dunk that this program is working ? Dropping the names of St Joe's and O'Hara really only reinforces the notion that public education is second rate and unless you have anywhere from $700 to over $1000 a month to donate in tuition fees your kid is not going anywhere. Did any of these kids apply to City Honors, Hutch or DaVinci ? God bless these kids and the Mrs. Langers of the world but can't we simply say this is a great opportunity without trying to backhand everyone else ? Teaching is a mission but I am starting to wonder about newspaper columnists.

SEAN CROWLEY, EDEN, NY on Thu Jul 7, 2011 at 09:59 AM

Add your comment

The Feed / What’s Happening Now

Latest Updates
Most Commented
Most Viewed
City of Buffalo

Ex-Bill Losman selling his Oakland Place home

Sabres & NHL

Sabres, Roy making their points

Courts

Corasanti's attorneys argue for dismissal

Lancaster

Lancaster union chief blasts head of NYSUT

Erie County

Sheriff's takeover of transit police eyed

Bucky Gleason

Boyes tries old routine to end slump

West Seneca

Couple lauded for a lifetime of love

Cheektowaga

Arrest made in Watkins' shooting death

Sabres & NHL

Miller remains sharp between the pipes

Niagara Falls

New company to run Maid of the Mist in Canada

Newsroom Tips

Have a news tip you think The Buffalo News should investigate?

Call The News tip line at 849-4475 or email us at investigations@buffnews.com.

All calls and emails will be kept confidential.

Buffalo Marketplace

Marketplace videos

Watch the latest offers, products and services from our advertisers.

Browse our print ads

It's the ultimate advantage for Buffalo consumers. Never miss another ad again!

Buffalo Savers: coupons

Buffalo coupons at your fingertips.
Just click and print. It's Easy!

close

Browse our print adsclose

Special Sections

Buffalo Saversclose

Local coupons

Featured coupon

Latest Blogs

Sports, Ink

This Day in Buffalo Sports History: The Boogie Man

SulliView

Reporter Marie Colvin died heroically, staying 'one more day' in a Syria under siege

BillBoard

'Mouse' McNally hired as Bengals consultant

Campus Watch

Ohio-UB live blog

Gusto

Remembering actor Neil Garvey