Skip to Main Navigation

The Buffalo News

Web Search
by YAHOO! SEARCH

Hero pilot lashes out against amendment

News Washington Bureau Chief

Published:March 30, 2011, 10:24 AM

Font Size:
  • E-mail
  • Share
  • Print

Related photos

More photos

Related stories

Recent Washington stories

Updated: March 31, 2011, 8:15 AM

WASHINGTON -- Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger, the hero pilot of the "Miracle on the Hudson," Wednesday lashed out against a Republican lawmaker's attempt to gut aviation safety legislation pushed into law last year by the Families of Continental Flight 3407.

"I think it represents a giant step backward in terms of aviation safety," said Sullenberger, who reached out to The Buffalo News to discuss the amendment put forth by Rep. Bill Shuster, R-Pa.

If Shuster's amendment becomes law, "at some point in the future, we don't know when, it's likely people will die unnecessarily," Sullenberger said.

Shuster's proposal, set for a House vote Thursday, would make it much more difficult for the government to impose tough standards to control pilot fatigue and to bolster pilot experience requirements.

The law passed last summer at the families' behest requires the government to draw up such standards. But under Shuster's proposed amendment, the Federal Aviation Administration would have to tailor new regulations to individual segments of the airline industry, such as passenger airlines, cargo carriers and charter operations.

"It totally guts our striving for one level of safety," Sullenberger said.

In addition, all the new regulations would be subject to a complex set of analyses before they could be implemented.

"It creates a huge obstacle to new regulations," Sullenberger said.

Charter operations are pushing the Shuster amendment, said the 3407 families, who started pushing for tougher aviation safety rules within months of the February 2009 crash in Clarence that claimed 50 lives.

However, the amendment could be applied to all segments of the airline industry, including passenger airlines, thereby stalling the pilot fatigue and experience rules the 3407 families fought for -- perhaps forever.

Sullenberger said he knows from experience the importance of making sure pilots are well rested. He said that if he and his co-pilot, Jeffrey Skiles, had been fatigued on the day their jet struck a flock of birds over New York in January 2009, they "could not have performed at the same level."

Sullenberger urged people to contact Shuster's office, as well as their own lawmakers, to fight the amendment.

Shuster's press secretary, Jeff Urbanchuk, did not respond to calls seeking comment on the amendment, which Shuster wants added to a bill reauthorizing funding for the FAA.

The House Rules Committee today voted to send Shuster's amendment to the floor.

Rep. Louise M. Slaughter of Fairport, the panel's top Democrat, lauded the Flight 3407 families as she worked in vain to kill the Shuster amendment.

"This [amendment] is an insult to them," Slaughter said.

The measure would make it impossible for the FAA to write safety rules in the time frame called for in the bill passed last year, said Kevin Kuwik, a leader of the 3407 families.

Kuwik was already in Washington lobbying against the Shuster amendment. As soon as they heard about the amendment, other key members of the families group began driving to Washington to join the fight.

First elected in 2002, Shuster received $18,500 in campaign money for his 2010 re-election and $115,750 throughout his career from the airline industry.

Shuster's amendment has a strong chance of passing the GOP-led House.

Still, "this isn't going down without a fight," said Rep. Brian Higgins, D-Buffalo.

Shuster's measure is expected to face a far rougher ride in the Senate, which is still controlled by Democrats.

"We are going to band together once again to beat back this senseless amendment and any other attempts to undermine the progress we've already made," said Sen. Charles E. Schumer, D-N.Y.

jzremski@buffnews.comnull

true

Comments

Sort:NEWEST FIRST | OLDEST FIRST

Pilot fatigue is a very serious issue, and the longer your day is the more rest you'll need at the end of it. When a filght gets delayed at the start of the day, it effects the entire day's schedule. You can only make up so much time in the air, and to make it up you need to burn more fuel, and more fuel burn equals more money and more money equals slimmer profit for that flight. In the end even the best intentions of airline executives have to be over-ridden by the fact that flights loose money all the time.

Pilots for the majors have far better conditions than those working at the regionals do. When you're a first officer for United or Delta on a triple 7 there is not much chance that you need to work a second job.

JEREMY LEWIS, BUFFALO, NY on Fri Apr 1, 2011 at 05:22 PM

Mr. Angello your comments come from the heart, very telling. Just another day at the office for a Rep. Legislature. Big business and profits once again rule the day.

PHIL RYAN, WEST SENECA, NY on Fri Apr 1, 2011 at 10:36 AM

"Mr. Thor in East Aurora wants us to look at this attempt to scuttle safety legislation through a purely apolitical lens. Fine. But why then go dragging us back to the days of slavery while trumpeting the big heartedness and largesse of the GOP ? Mr. Thor's cynical notion that America has historically chosen dollars over people since its inception, while partly true, is equally insulting to the efforts of family members of the victims and aviation professionals like Mr. Sullenberger."
Sean, it is appropriate to recognize that history before our lifetimes is worth looking at, and to recognize that profit has come before people too often in the country's history and that it has not been defended or challenged by any one political party. I also made clear, in another post, that Mr. Sullenberger is a recognized expert in the field of aviation history and has been for years and that, as absurd as it would be to care what political views he held, so should it be equally absurd to present Schuster's amendment as a "Democrat vs. Republican" situation. I also found a pilot's organization that presents more information about the bill being heard and how easy it is, on their site, to notify their federal officials if they feel the Schuster amendment is inappropriate. I also happen to believe the issue of pilot fatigue won't be adequately achieved in this bill, as I understand it to be written, but it's a start.
Finally, Sean, to link this amendment to the "war on working people" doesn't recognize that an aviation accident is non-discriminating in terms of whether "working people" or others are involved; it affects them all. You may agree with little I wrote, but hopefully we both agree the amendment should be defeated.

DAVID THOR, EAST AURORA, NY on Thu Mar 31, 2011 at 11:23 PM

Mr. Thor in East Aurora wants us to look at this attempt to scuttle safety legislation through a purely apolitical lens. Fine. But why then go dragging us back to the days of slavery while trumpeting the big heartedness and largesse of the GOP ? Mr. Thor's cynical notion that America has historically chosen dollars over people since its inception, while partly true, is equally insulting to the efforts of family members of the victims and aviation professionals like Mr. Sullenberger. Evil will always have its way if good people stand back and do nothing. In this case good people like the families, organized labor, Mr. Sullenberger and even Chris Lee, a one time elected Republican, stepped up to see that the evil notion of saving a buck at the expense of our loved ones is challenged head on. I applaud them and support their efforts. If your political party keeps coming up on the wrong side of these arguments and you can't see how corporate greed like we saw in the Gulf of Mexico, in the coal mines of Appalachia and the multi-million dollar bonuses paid to banker/failures who nearly put us into another Depression, almost always seem to be tied conspicuously to your party, maybe it's time you to stop defending them and get honest about what's really going on in this shrinking corporate oligarchy we used to call planet earth. It's pretty clear to anyone with 2 eyes and ears what's going on in Ohio, Wisconsin, Indiana and Florida. We call it the war on working people and the crash of 3407 is yet another of its atrocities.

SEAN CROWLEY, EDEN, NY on Thu Mar 31, 2011 at 07:53 PM

"It`s things like this that scream we have lost everything good that America once was when we choose dollars over people."
Robert, perhaps the ultimate American example of choosing dollars over people is the acceptance of slavery, which, if you follow a detailed timeline at http://www.pbs.org/wnet/slavery/timeline/index.html, lasted from 1619-1874 and during which Republicans spearheaded the often-challenged effort to abolish it, which is why having the News turn this into a "Democrat vs Republican" story is both insulting and irrelevant, but apparantly they feel it best appeals to their target audience. The point is, America has, I think, often chosen dollars over people for its entire history.
Back to the issue of the pilot fatigue amendment, it is not certain that Schuster was bought out by any particular lobby, nevertheless the notion that different types of flights should have different fatigue standards is absurd. The fact is, a cargo plane crashing in a densely-populated area could kill as many people as a fully-loaded jumbo jet crashing in an empty field. I don't think the un-amended pilot fatigue law goes far enough, since it defines length of rest periods as mitigating pilot fatigue; I think that there should be basic tests performed before the start of a pilot's flight to determine if they are fit to fly. Perhaps this isn't feasible at this time and the rest period enforcement is the best that can be accomplished today, but I think that long-term, pilots should be asked to demonstrate fitness before flying, not just being able to prove they had "x" number of hours between shifts.

DAVID THOR, EAST AURORA, NY on Thu Mar 31, 2011 at 06:16 PM

Great comment Mr. Agnello. Sad but so very true.

JEREMY LEWIS, BUFFALO, NY on Thu Mar 31, 2011 at 04:14 PM

Mr. Angello, we have not and will never loose "...everything good that America once was...". Not as long as men like yourself stand up and make themselves heard. Thank you so much.

ROBERT H. MACCALLUM, SLOAN, NY on Thu Mar 31, 2011 at 03:47 PM

When is the insanity going to stop? When will politicians stop selling us out? When will they go back to governing for the people and not the corporations? Really it is time. This country has had about about as much as it can take. They seem to make no decisions which do not benefit big business at the expense of the rest of us. Over and over and over. Money and the pursuit of it by big companies has become the sole priority and deciding factor in just about everything.

And just as bad how the industry goes through the motions all along with sob stories knowing full well they are feeding us all a bunch of lies. And behind closed doors plotting how they will water down any legislation and go back to business as usual. The business of overworking, under training and underpaying their employees so they can make maximum profits no matter who lives or dies.

And to think my cousin, a retired Senior Master Sergeant who made a career of serving and protecting them for 30 years in the United States Air Force, surviving Vietnam, Operation Desert Storm and two tours in the Iraq War had to die that day so the the industry could essentially save a few dollars.

It`s things like this that scream we have lost everything good that America once was when we choose dollars over people.

ROBERT AGNELLO, GRAND ISLAND, NY on Thu Mar 31, 2011 at 09:34 AM

Unfortunately, but predictably and insultingly, the News is incapable of presenting any public issue as anything other than a Democrat vs. Republican matter. Sullenberger is an expert on airline safety, and it makes no difference what his party affiliation happens to be. For some straightforward information on the issue from a purely-pilot perspective, visit http://www.capapilots.org/history and after reading additional information besides what the News chose to print, there is a "contact your legislators" button that makes it easy to have your voice counted if you feel this amendment is a bad idea.

DAVID THOR, EAST AURORA, NY on Thu Mar 31, 2011 at 02:58 AM

$115,750 from the airline industry? Money well spent from their point of view I suppose. After all, they are just pilots and passengers. Pilots are just labor. Who cares? Representative Schuster was bought and paid for all legal like. And the rest of us can have a grand ol' time watching the show once Schuster's spin team has a chance to redefine everything for us. Man, I wish I could afford to purchase a few politicians. Maybe Walmart can get the price down, bring 'em in from China.
What say ye Pennsylvania?

ROBERT H. MACCALLUM, SLOAN, NY on Wed Mar 30, 2011 at 10:10 PM

1 2
Add your comment

Real Estate Transactions »

Search our home sales transactions database that contains the selling price of every home in Erie County since 2006.

Advanced search »

Politics Now Blog

Politics Updates

The Feed / What’s Happening Now

Latest Updates
Most Commented
Most Viewed
Sabres & NHL

Sabres, Miller jump for Roy in shootout

Bills & NFL

Bills need to take step, but won't reach

Sabres & NHL

Sabres let a point slip away in overtime

Bucky Gleason

Five-point gap in race more than a stretch

Bills & NFL

Progress made in talks with Johnson

Southern Tier

Accusation of crack pipe in bra leads to new charge

Niagara Falls

Falls man charged in rape of girl, 14

Margaret Sullivan

Okun steps away from the table

Weather

High winds drop trees, but snow stays behind

North Buffalo/Hertel

Zoo opens doors to protect a rare breed

Newsroom Tips

Have a news tip you think The Buffalo News should investigate?

Call The News tip line at 849-4475 or email us at investigations@buffnews.com.

All calls and emails will be kept confidential.

Buffalo Marketplace

Marketplace videos

Watch the latest offers, products and services from our advertisers.

Browse our print ads

It's the ultimate advantage for Buffalo consumers. Never miss another ad again!

Buffalo Savers: coupons

Buffalo coupons at your fingertips.
Just click and print. It's Easy!

close

Browse our print adsclose

Special Sections

Buffalo Saversclose

Local coupons

Featured coupon