Skip to Main Navigation

The Buffalo News

Web Search
by YAHOO! SEARCH

As global warming alters ecology, economy will change, report says

NEWS ALBANY BUREAU

Published:November 16, 2011, 11:10 AM

Font Size:
  • E-mail
  • Share
  • Print

Recent Albany stories

Updated: November 16, 2011, 10:29 PM

ALBANY -- Warmer winters and longer lake-effect snow seasons.

Summers hotter by nine degrees.

Lower levels of water in the Great Lakes.

The demise of New York's MacIntosh and Empire apples.

Poor conditions for brook trout and salmon; better conditions for bass.

Climate change will radically transform New York State by 2080 in ways unimaginable today, affecting everything from the kinds of birds flying overhead to the crops farmers will be able to grow, according to a report released Wednesday.

More than 50 scientists worked three years to complete the study, which is intended to send a wake-up call to residents, urban planners, water resource managers and businesses with a simple message: New York must begin now to adapt to a warming climate over the coming decades.

"We have to realize that a lot of the things we do today, the crops we grow, how water systems are designed, are based on climate data 50 years old," said Arthur DeGaetano, one of the study's principal investigators. "But with climate change, we have to start incrementally rethinking how they might change."

DeGaetano is a researcher from Cornell University. The report was released by Clim-

AID, a group of researchers from a variety of disciplines from Cornell, Columbia University, the City University of New York and other institutions. "The state has the potential capacity to address many climate-related risks, thereby reducing negative impacts and taking advantage of possible opportunities,"

The 600-page study provides insight into how communities across the Empire State will be hit by climate change over the next 70 years. The $1.5 million study was funded by the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority, a state agency.

An authority spokesman said the three-year study cost $1.5 million, which was matched by the universities in staff time and other resources.

The study comes as global warming remains a controversial issue for some Americans, though polls tend to find that most Americans believe the climate is changing. Some conservatives say the global warming issue is fueled by environmentalists seeking to achieve political changes that will end up hurting business interests.

"Science is not only not settled on this issue, but science has been proven wrong on many of these studies over the years," said Michael Long, the state Conservative Party chairman. "Sometimes, you can't look that far into the future."

The ClimAID study's snapshots of various regions provides sobering predictions -- from lower Great Lakes water levels to less snow in winter tourist regions and even the loss of MacIntosh apple crops.

It also found a few bright spots, such as new opportunities for Western New York grape growers to plant more wine grapes that now can't cope with cold climates.

But for the bright spots, there often was a price. Warmer winters will mean shorter periods of ice cover on lakes Erie and Ontario, which will extend shipping seasons. The price: longer lake-effect snow seasons.

Climate change already is affecting the state, as witnessed by historic floods in areas not prone before to such tragedies, the report said.

"Climate change-related economic impacts will be experienced in all sectors, types of communities and regions across the state," the report said.

The report's scientists offered many ways for the state to adapt to the changing climate: planting more low-pollen trees in cities to reduce summer temperatures, buying out or offering land swaps to homes and businesses in major wetland or flood zone areas, the making of a major energy conservation effort by the state, and improving coordination to reduce invasive plant species to preserve wetlands and existing animal species.

But the report also made clear there will be no way to ignore the impact of climate change on our lives.

Take the fishing industry. Cold water fish, such as brook trout and Atlantic salmon, will have a harder time surviving in New York waters. At the same time, more bass stocks could appear.

Climate changes will especially hurt smaller upstate communities that rely on the $3.5 billion fishing and hunting seasons to keep their economies going.

Climate change will prove an expensive problem for the state, the report said.

By the middle of the century, annual costs associated with climate change, such as more flooding from more flash storms or hurricanes, will top $10 billion annually in the state.

Climate change also will bring hotter weather. The study predicted average annual temperatures being 4 degrees to 9 degrees higher by 2080, with upstate feeling the heat the most, according to the report.

The elderly and low-income residents and those in rural areas will be especially hit by such changes as they struggle with costs of air conditioning to keep cool.

Precipitation levels will be up 5 percent to 15 percent -- much of it as additional rain in the winter. The projections, the study said, do not factor in "significant" polar ice sheet melting. However, the study noted that "sharp cuts" in global emissions could reduce those predictions.

Farmers also will be hit hard by the changing conditions.

Predictions of more winter rain may be accompanied by periods of drought in other seasons, forcing farmers to turn to costly irrigation systems.

Farmers also will face new pest populations.

Dairy farms will see milk production fall unless farmers can adapt through such means as installing more efficient cooling systems in barns.

Farms, which now cover one-fourth of the state, will have to undergo dramatic transformations, even changing the types of crops that are planted.

The report talked of more opportunities to grow valuable European wine grapes, such as those grown in California.

But the state's apple farmers will have to adapt by growing more heat-tolerant varieties, likely causing the disappearance in New York of MacIntosh and Empire apples.

Transportation and water resource systems will face the most significant impact from climate change unless there are major infrastructure changes. Hydropower plants will have less water during summer and utilities across the state will be especially strained during the hottest periods to provide reliable power.

Coastal areas will face permanent inundation of wetlands. Saltwater levels -- which can now stretch to the Poughkeepsie area during some high tides -- will go farther north up the Hudson River.

The state's forests won't be able to escape the effects of weather change, either.

The report predicted "widespread shifts" in various plant, tree and animal species in forests. It said the spruce-fir forests in the Adirondacks and Catskills will be threatened, as will alpine tundra and boreal plant communities. Climate change will encourage invasive species, such as the kudzu, to flourish unless officials undertake a more comprehensive reporting and extraction system.

Health effects will range from more asthma cases to higher levels of stress and mental health concerns for people living near flood zones.

To mitigate and adapt to the effects of climate change, government and private businesses will face major expenditures.

The report said, for example, longer airport runways will be needed to help pilots cope with less lift to get their planes aloft during hot periods.

It said low-lying water treatment facilities and high-density housing in areas that could be susceptible to flooding should be relocated to higher grounds. That could require zoning changes to deal with future construction plans for such communities.

It also called for more levees, sea walls and pumping stations to help communities cope with flooding.

As the timing and durations of the seasons change, tourism will have to adapt. Less snow in many areas will hurt ski operations and snowmobile areas. But longer summers could promote other tourism.

The report stressed how various sectors can start to consider specific ways to adapt to the coming changes.

"Adaptations can take place at the individual, household, community, organization and institutional level," the report said. It could mean everything from better community planning to more energy conservation by homeowners.

But it acknowledged some solutions could lead to other problems. Building sea walls, for instance could further erode wetlands. Increasing air conditioning for people and farm animals will further stress the state's already strained power grid.

Texas Gov. Rick Perry, one of the contenders for the Republican presidential nomination, is among those who disagrees with the climate change researchers, going so far as to call global warming claims "contrived" by scientists.

"I also believe industry and commerce must do everything they can to take the right steps to avoid polluting our atmosphere, but one thing we don't need is the strong arm and heavy hand of government making it impossible for industry to exist in this state," Long added.

Climate change already is being felt in the form of warmer winters in New York over the last several decades and increasing numbers of extreme rainfall events, according to DeGaetano, the Cornell researcher, who is the director of the Northeast Regional Climate Center at Cornell.

"The report says what we can start to do about it now," DeGaetano said.

The study offers a blueprint for how communities can adjust things like zoning and planning considerations when, for example, deciding whether to build new housing complexes near a flood zone or replacing aging sewer treatment facilities that are often located along rivers, the researcher said. He cautioned that not all the adaptive costs are prohibitive, nor do they all have to be met immediately.

"In most cases, what doesn't have to happen is an overall paradigm shift. It's in our planning, our policymaking, our regulations.

tprecious@buffnews.com null

true

Comments

Sort:NEWEST FIRST | OLDEST FIRST

Jorgen Steffensen, PhD, Center for Ice and Climate, University of Copenhagen, has stated that the beginning of our modern warm age began some 11, 714 years ago. That was the start of the end of the last ice age. Steffensen and his team of researchers determined this by examining ice cores from the NorthGRIP deep drilling program in Greenland.

This brings up some interesting questions for all the "man-made" global warming scientists and enthusiasts. Here are just a few of them:

When exactly did the natural global warming process end?
What made natural global warming end?
Why was the world not informed that natural global warming ended?
When exactly did "man-made" global warming begin?
What was the time period between the end of natural global warming and the start of "man-made" global warming called?

MICHALE SZYMANSKI, ORCHARD PARK, NY on Fri Nov 18, 2011 at 03:04 PM

Don, now you're just making things up - I guess that's the same when you're extemporaneously giving us the weather 'off the cuff,' as you stated earlier.

Satellite studies debunked, not peer reviewed? Really? See 2011 attached study from NASA. Source seems more credible than Don Paul, weatherman from Buffalo. These are real experts, not self-appointed experts like you.

http://news.yahoo.com/nasa-data-blow-gaping-hold-global-warming-alarmism-192334971.html.

You love to name-call, Don. I guess you're not only thin-skinned, but also have a Napoleon-complex. I guess if most of your friends are flaky liberal, and you're only liberal, you're a moderate....in your world. I didn't think you were a Ted Baxter before this, but now I see more of a 'Don' Burgundy with a splash of Brick Tamblin.

BRENDAN CULLINAN, CLARENCE CENTER, NY on Fri Nov 18, 2011 at 06:49 AM

I'm with Don Paul on this one. As warming continues to accelerate across the planet, even those who once refused to accept the scientific conclusions set forth in the IPCC reports are now accepting of the facts, including chief skeptic Richard Muller from Berkeley National Laboratory. I was a student of one of best known climatologists in the country, Reid Bryson, at the University of Wisconsin. He concluded in the 1960's that globe was cooling. It was about the same time that we were receiving new data from Mauna Loa, the Antarctic, and other reporting stations that CO2 levels were rising. Other samples taken from around the world were consistent. We looked backward through ice cores and tree ring data and had to conclude that indeed CO2 and temperature were actually rising at an exponential rate--the "hockey stick" graph. The relationship between CO2 and temperature has been known for a century or more. The world is warming and it is changing our climate. The impact on the Great Lakes Basin Ecosystem will be profound.

TERRY YONKER, YOUNGSTOWN, NY on Fri Nov 18, 2011 at 12:16 AM

Gee, if you say so, I guess I DO read a teleprompter. I could have sworn I didn't, but since you were wrong on everything else you claimed, from satellite studies (which were discredited in peer review some years ago), to the amount of solar variance, to the level of knowledge of some other weathercasters, to whom you think I vote for and consider my climate experts, you're WAY overdue to be right about something Brendan. So, even though I don't read a teleprompter, I have to weigh the odds in your imaginary little paranoid existence. I must have just imagined I don't read a teleprompter.

DON PAUL, EAST AMHERST, NY on Thu Nov 17, 2011 at 11:53 PM

Don, I never said John Coleman had a degree in meteorology. I remember him saying once he had a degree in journalism or communications - something like that. He read a teleprompter - like you, and there's nothing wrong with that. So did Dave Thomas (aka Dave Roberts, aka Dave Boreanaz). John Coleman never fancied himself an expert. You do (and you're not).

Wow, do you have a thin skin.

I'll believe the pole to pole satellite studies; you can stay with your subsidized studies from subsidized scientists that create subsidized data for further subsidized studies. Nice cottage industry.

BRENDAN CULLINAN, CLARENCE CENTER, NY on Thu Nov 17, 2011 at 11:19 PM

Correction: Never OVERestimate an internet buffoon. By the way, there are "certificates in broadcast meteorology" available over the internet. There is no full degree program available via correspondence.

And, no weathercaster, meteorologist or not, "reads a teleprompter." We speak off the cuff.


DON PAUL, EAST AMHERST, NY on Thu Nov 17, 2011 at 11:12 PM

Brendan,

John Coleman never took a course in meteorology, let alone major in it in college. He was once a great broadcaster, nothing more than that other than being an entrepreneur. He ain't MY Al Gore, bub. I must say, after reading your latest comments, you're dumber on this material than I first gave you credit for. Never underestimate an internet buffoon.

DON PAUL, EAST AMHERST, NY on Thu Nov 17, 2011 at 10:56 PM

Don, not to burst your bubble, but your most important job is to read a teleprompter. A BS in meteorology earned 40+ yrs ago does not make you an expert. Meteorology degrees can be earned online. Continuing education reinforces knowledge of heuristics other experts have developed. You called yourself an expert. I would hardly consider you an expert other than in your own, inflated ego.

Why does John Coleman, founder of the Weather Channel, consider global warming "a fictional, manufactured crisis, and a total scam?" He was in all the big markets - Chicago, NYC, So Cal - a little better than Buffalo. He states emphatically that many scientists and politicians have been embroiled in fraudulent activity based on incomplete science and a political motive for a one-world government.

Do I consider John Coleman an expert? No, but he sure shows the best experts to access and ascertain - better than Don Paul from Buffalo. He knows which experts to believe, and which frauds to be leery of. As a founder of the Weather Channel, I'd put my money on John Coleman's opinion versus Don Paul.

Keep believing Al Gore, buffoon extraordinaire and climate 'expert.' Yes, that Al Gore who said just a couple kilometers down beneath the Earth's are some very, very hot rocks - because the Earth crust is SEVERAL MILLION degrees. Your climate expert, Al Gore - wrong answer - Earth's core approx 4000oC (7232oF). But keep believing your 'experts' with their suspicious agendas and concocted data.

BRENDAN CULLINAN, CLARENCE CENTER, NY on Thu Nov 17, 2011 at 10:51 PM

Don,

[Based on what 3 climate scientists from Goddard told us 2 years ago at my AMS conference, yes, I'm sure--because they're sure.]

Well that's very interesting to note. Thanks for all of your insightful commentary on the issue. It was very informative and well appreciated (by some anyways) :)

RICK BRIDENBAKER, WEST SENECA, NY on Thu Nov 17, 2011 at 10:43 PM

Based on what 3 climate scientists from Goddard told us 2 years ago at my AMS conference, yes, I'm sure--because they're sure.

DON PAUL, EAST AMHERST, NY on Thu Nov 17, 2011 at 10:34 PM

1 2 3 4 5 6
Add your comment

Real Estate Transactions »

Search our home sales transactions database that contains the selling price of every home in Erie County since 2006.

Advanced search »

Politics Now Blog

Politics Updates

The Feed / What’s Happening Now

Latest Updates
Most Commented
Most Viewed
Sabres & NHL

Sabres, Miller jump for Roy in shootout

Bills & NFL

Bills need to take step, but won't reach

Sabres & NHL

Sabres let a point slip away in overtime

Bucky Gleason

Five-point gap in race more than a stretch

Bills & NFL

Progress made in talks with Johnson

Southern Tier

Accusation of crack pipe in bra leads to new charge

Niagara Falls

Falls man charged in rape of girl, 14

Margaret Sullivan

Okun steps away from the table

Weather

High winds drop trees, but snow stays behind

North Buffalo/Hertel

Zoo opens doors to protect a rare breed

Newsroom Tips

Have a news tip you think The Buffalo News should investigate?

Call The News tip line at 849-4475 or email us at investigations@buffnews.com.

All calls and emails will be kept confidential.

Buffalo Marketplace

Marketplace videos

Watch the latest offers, products and services from our advertisers.

Browse our print ads

It's the ultimate advantage for Buffalo consumers. Never miss another ad again!

Buffalo Savers: coupons

Buffalo coupons at your fingertips.
Just click and print. It's Easy!

close

Browse our print adsclose

Special Sections

Buffalo Saversclose

Local coupons

Featured coupon