by YAHOO! SEARCH
Paterson defies Legislature on education aid
Updated: August 21, 2010, 10:25 AM
ALBANY — Gov. David A. Paterson wasted little time Monday night vetoing some of
the last major spending portions of the budget that had breezed through the State Legislature
just hours earlier.
The governor took out his veto stamp, with reporters as his witnesses, to strike out $419
million in education spending he said is politically popular in an election year but
unaffordable for the state.
And he said more vetoes are coming — 6,900 of them in line-item fashion.
"Rather than act in the interest of the people of New York State, [legislators] have
engaged in legislation that is in self-interest and have presented us with a series of bills
that have the same gimmicks, chicanery and avoidance conduct that has characterized fiscal
management in this state for far too long," Paterson said.
The vetoes came as a major push to give more financial autonomy to the State University of
New York — an integral part of the University at Buffalo's expansion plans —
appeared all but dead Monday night.
Lawmakers approved the last major spending bills of the budget for 2010-11, the fiscal year
that began April 1, with no one being able to say with any certainty how much the overall plan
will cost taxpayers.
The Democratic-led Assembly and Senate passed the massive section of the budget that
provides state aid to 700 school districts, restoring $600 million — $419 million during
the state's current fiscal year — in the coming school year above what Paterson
proposed.
Before lawmakers had time to boast of the additional school money in news releases
back home, Paterson whacked the extra money — daring them to try to get the two-thirds
necessary in the two chambers for an override.
"You can't spend money you don't have," Paterson said.
In Albany today, political games were an inch below the surface.
The Senate Judiciary Committee, which was to meet to consider three judgeship nominations
by Paterson, canceled the session in a slap at Paterson.
And an Assembly-Senate office that drafts legislation has stopped doing any drafting work
on Paterson bills, officials say .
Despite vows on Monday to pass today the revenue bill, including tax hikes, both houses are
now looking to push that off until Thursday. The move buys time for possible negotiation with
Paterson on budget issues, and for the two houses to decide if they want to try to pursue
overrides of the Paterson vetoes.
The Senate Republicans, whose members voted against the Monday budget bills, were being coy
... or at least not firm ... about their override intentions. In a six-paragraph statement, Senate
Republican Leader Dean Skelos condemned the budget bills approved Monday.
"They should not expect or count on Senate Republicans to bail them out of the mess that
they have made of this budget and the damage they are inflicting on taxpayers," Skelos said.
His aides declined, however, to flatly rule out Senate GOP votes to help Democrats in any
override attempt.
Democrats in the Legislature
condemned Paterson's vetoes, though Republicans in the Senate voted against the added spending and
seem uninterested in helping in any override effort. The vetoes included $33 million in
restorations beyond what the governor said was affordable for schools in Erie County and $10
million in Niagara County.
The last of the budget bills are being taken up today, including one totaling more than 300
pages that would raise more than $1 billion in various taxes and fees, such as higher sales
taxes on clothing purchases, online hotel bookings and charitable donations by wealthy people.
It also puts into law the ability for gay couples married in other states or countries to list
themselves as married for New York State income tax purposes.
And then this morning, Paterson took to the radio airwaves during rush hour, bashing the Legislature
on radio shows from Buffalo to New York City.
The Legislature left a hole of as much as $500 million with its final round of spending
bills, the governor said.
In addition, another $1 billion may not be coming Albany's way in federal Medicaid
reimbursement ... a problem facing dozens of states that planned on the funds.
On WOR in New York, Paterson sounded a threat no lawmaker wants him to pursue: force the
Legislature to return to Albany closer to this fall's re-election campaigns to consider more
cuts to close the deficit they are leaving unresolved this week.
"There's kind of an understanding that the governor will not call the Legislature back
during the election. I will, because they left this hole," Paterson said.
The governor likened the Legislature to credit card addicts who keep spending without ways
to pay for it.
"This is government acting in way (that), if this were an individual, you'd say they need
counseling," Paterson said.
In a television interview on CNBC, the governor said he will go to Washington this week with other governors to plead the states' case for the need for the full Medicaid federal funding. Paterson said 30 states were banking on the added Mediciad funds.
Meanwhile, the obituary was written for the proposal pushed by UB and the rest of SUNY to
permit the public colleges to raise tuition and to more freely engage in partnerships with
private companies.
The plan fell to opposition in the Assembly after two Senate Democrats — including
Sen. William T. Stachowski of Lake View — backed off a threat to withhold their crucial
votes on the education bill if the SUNY plan were not included.
Stachowski and Senate Democratic leaders insisted they still have leverage in the coming
days — including a threat not to vote tuetoday for the final revenue portion of the
budget — to push the Assembly on the effort giving SUNY more financial autonomy from the
state. One idea calls for "carving out" UB and the State University at Stony Brook to let it
begin the program on a pilot basis.
But a key lawmaker in the Assembly called that idea a nonstarter. "I think that has very
little support in our conference," said Assembly Higher Education Committee Chairwoman Deborah
J. Glick, D-Manhattan, who believes that the SUNY plan would harm low-income students.
"Frankly, I really don't understand why people in the Western New York region can go back
and tell the working- and middle-class people in their districts, "UB is going to be great,
but you won't be able to afford to go,'" Glick said.
The level of drama peaked Monday afternoon when the first budget bill of the day —
covering aid to public schools and SUNY, as well as a variety of social services programs
— was pulled from the Senate floor at Stachowski's request. The lawmaker then huddled
behind closed doors with Senate leaders before emerging to say he would not hold up passage of
the bill. All 32 Democratic votes in the Senate have been needed to pass budget bills because
Republicans have been voting in a bloc against them.
Stachowski and Senate Democratic Conference Leader John L. Sampson of Brooklyn sought to
put a positive spin on the maneuver, insisting they can still prod the Assembly their way
before the 2010 legislative ends likely in the coming days. Sampson said he "will do all I
can" to get the SUNY plan approved this week.
But Republicans said the issue died when Senate Democrats passed the higher-education bill
without the SUNY component. "It's absolutely dead. We've given up all of our leverage in
negotiations with the Assembly," said Sen. George D. Maziarz, R-Newfane. "UB 2020 will not
happen this year, which is just another knife in the back to Western New York," Maziarz said
of the UB plan that proposes a major expansion of the campus in downtown Buffalo.
Some backers of UB 2020, which envisions thousands of new jobs in the Buffalo area, said
Stachowski and Sen. Antoine M. Thompson, D-Buffalo, should have used their crucial votes on
the budget to get the SUNY bill, which lawmakers had been calling the biggest "ask" this year
of the state by the Western New York delegation.
"They didn't deliver," said Sam Capitano, vice president of the Buffalo Construction Trades
Council, who said thousands of construction jobs are on the line.
"Our politicians from Erie County have no stroke here. Western New York gets the shaft
again," said Capitano, who is also the business manager of the Laborers Local 210 in Buffalo.
In the Assembly, Crystal D. Peoples-Stokes, D-Buffalo, said downstate Democrats could not
be convinced to back the SUNY plan. "I'm disappointed. I think it's a mistake," Peoples-Stokes
said of the Assembly's opposition to the SUNY plan. "A majority of members with SUNY campuses
in their districts could have voted for this, but were not given the opportunity."
Critics say the plan hit low-income students by not keeping grants under the Tuition
Assistance Program on pace with future tuition increases.
Paterson, who proposed the SUNY plan, said lawmakers who blocked it had "sent a strong
message" that they "prefer mediocrity in our public colleges and universities."
The public education piece passed by lawmakers Monday steered $200 million of the $600
million in restorations to the state's Big Five districts. Of that, $177 million was for New
York City; $7 million would go to Buffalo. The remaining $400 million was spread across the
state — at least for the two hours before Paterson vetoed the spending Monday night.
Lawmakers rejected Paterson's proposal to cap local property taxes. They plan Wednesday to
pass a bill driving a portion of the additional school aid money they restored — but
Paterson vetoed — toward property tax cuts this summer. The amount would have been
modest — $271 million spread statewide. By contrast, the sales tax increase on clothing
and shoe purchases would bring Albany $330 million in higher revenues this year.
Before Monday, about 70 percent of the budget had already been passed in weekly emergency
bills since the budget became late when the fiscal year began. Besides money for public
schools, lawmakers restored spending that Paterson wanted to trim to SUNY, community colleges
and grants for college students. And they added back money for adult homeless shelters, child
care grants to localities and foster care programs.
Paterson said the added legislative spending threatened to "put the finances of New Yorkers
in jeopardy." He said the Legislature also ignored his call to come up with a contingency
plan, as already embraced in other states, in the growing chance that New York will get as
much as $1 billion less in federal Medicaid reimbursement this year.
advertisement
Entertainment Calendar
Best bets:
- Thu 2/9: Umphrey's McGee
- Thu 2/9: Don Felder -- An Evening at the Hotel California
- Fri 2/10: Brian Regan
- Fri 2/10: Don Felder -- An Evening at the Hotel California
- Sat 2/11: Rita Coolidge
- Sat 2/11: Sha Na Na
- Sat 2/11: Chris Webby
- Sat 2/11: Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra: Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto
- Sat 2/11: Don Felder -- An Evening at the Hotel California
- Sun 2/12: Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra: Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto
- Sun 2/12: Bill Medley
- more events »
The Feed / What’s Happening Now
Boy fatally struck by car in Jamestown identified
Senecas bolster spending to fight casino plans
Niagara SPCA board member resigns
Sabres show some gumption in beating Bruins
Woman, 24, found dead in car
Bills hire a quarterback mechanic in Lee
Sabres find the missing ingredients
Ruff to remain in press box for awhile
Answers to the many questions in Le Roy
Driver killed as collision closes Thruway lanes
Stay Informed
Newsroom Tips
Have a news tip you think The Buffalo News should investigate?
Call The News tip line at 849-4475 or email us at investigations@buffnews.com.
All calls and emails will be kept confidential.
Buffalo Marketplace
Marketplace videos
Watch the latest offers, products and services from our advertisers.
Browse our print ads
It's the ultimate advantage for Buffalo consumers. Never miss another ad again!
Buffalo Savers: coupons
Buffalo coupons at your fingertips.
Just click and print. It's Easy!

