Family Dollar Stores spurned a $9 billion offer from Dollar General Corp. in favor of a lower bid from Dollar Tree, saying it was concerned the Dollar General deal wouldn’t be able to pass antitrust hurdles.
The board rejected the Dollar General proposal and reaffirmed last month’s pact to merge with Dollar Tree, according to a statement Thursday from the Matthews, N.C.-based company. Dollar Tree has agreed to pay about $8.5 billion, excluding debt.
“Our board reviewed, with our advisers, all aspects of Dollar General’s proposal and unanimously concluded that it is not reasonably likely to be completed on the terms proposed,” CEO Howard R. Levine said in the statement.
The Dollar General offer, made this week, would merge the two largest dollar store chains in the U.S., creating a fleet of almost 20,000 stores. While Dollar General planned to sell 700 locations to appease regulators, Family Dollar believes it may have to unload a larger number than that, potentially more than 1,000, according to people familiar with the company’s thinking.
The three companies have stores across the Buffalo Niagara region: Family Dollar has 23; Dollar General, 21; and Dollar Tree, 18.
Dollar General offered $78.50 a share in cash, compared with Dollar Tree’s bid of $74.50 a share in cash and stock. The deal was expected to generate $550 million to $600 million in annual cost savings. Family Dollar shares fell by 0.4 percent Thursday to close at $79.41, in New York; Dollar General dropped by 0.15 percent, closing at $63.61.
“As a shareholder, I wouldn’t be happy about the board rejecting a 5 percent premium over Dollar Tree’s bid,” said Poonam Goyal, a senior retail analyst for Bloomberg Intelligence. “There are more synergies with Dollar General and comparable business models.”
Dollar General CEO Richard W. Dreiling had sought to assuage Family Dollar’s concerns in a letter to the board Tuesday, saying that experienced counsel and an economist had reviewed the antitrust question.
“We are confident that we will be able to quickly and efficiently resolve any potential antitrust issues,” Dreiling said in the letter. “We believe that the number of store divestitures contained in our offer letter is more than sufficient to take this issue completely off the table.”
Family Dollar wanted Dollar General to agree to take on any antitrust risks before accepting any deal with the company, said the person with knowledge of the matter. That may have involved paying a fee to Family Dollar if regulators blocked the deal, according to the person.
Levine said that Dreiling’s letter did nothing to address the regulatory issues. Dollar General also refused to meet to discuss antitrust concerns during earlier talks in June, Family Dollar said.
Family Dollar’s rejection of the Dollar General offer follows growing tensions between the two companies, which have had fruitless talks in the past about a potential merger. In his letter, Dreiling said he felt misled by previous discussions with Family Dollar, which didn’t reveal that it was close to a deal with Dollar Tree.
“We have presented you with a superior proposal for your shareholders (although perhaps not for Mr. Levine personally),” Dreiling said.
Levine said that Dreiling’s letter contained “blatant mischaracterizations.”
Dollar General, based in Goodlettsville, Tenn., needs the Family Dollar deal to maintain its lead in the market. A merger between Family Dollar and Dollar Tree would combine the Nos. 2 and 3 competitors in the industry, creating the largest U.S. dollar store chain in terms of store count.
A Dollar Tree-led merger would still involve divesting stores to pacify regulators, though the company doesn’t expect to have to get rid of more than 500.
The battle for Family Dollar began after activist investors Carl C. Icahn and Nelson Peltz took large stakes in the retailer and then pushed for a sale. Icahn still owns about 3.6 percent of the shares, while Peltz’s Trian Fund Management LP has a 7.3 percent stake.