Dear Carolyn: How do I break the news to my friend that I have been seeing her (recent) ex-boyfriend? I’m prepared to lose the friendship, but I want to minimize how hurt she gets, if possible. I guess I’m thinking specifically of altering the timeline, so there’s more distance between when they broke up and when we started dating.
A: You and he have already taken the action that hurts your friend, so there’s no altering history to cover your backsides. There’s only consideration of how much of the truth she needs, for her sake, and supplying it accordingly.
Without the details, I can only guess at that magic quantity. However, most in her position need only the fact of your dating. That, and respect; no fibbing.
What your friendship needs, meanwhile, is for her to hear it first from you.
Combined, those dictate a simple statement, soon: “Ex and I are seeing each other. I wanted you to hear it from me first.”
If she asks when it started, please use this truth instead: “Any time is too close to your breakup, isn’t it?” Meaning, admit fault out of integrity and skip the details out of compassion. If she insists, she assumes the risk of knowing all. Honor that with the truth.
Sister needs help
Dear Carolyn: My husband’s sister conducted a two-year affair and her marriage ended. Sister blames Ex for the failure of their marriage, refuses to admit to the affair, stalks Ex’s dates and otherwise harasses Ex, continually cancels her days with her children and disparages her own children to Ex.
Because Ex has always acted like a brother to my husband, and because we want to be a source of stability for the children, we remain close to Ex.
We also believe Sister’s behavior indicates a need for help, but she refuses therapy.
Sister tries to disrupt our time with Ex and children, screaming and crying that our relationship with Ex is “preventing her from moving on with her life.”
We have never disclosed her affair to anyone. I don’t know if revealing some details would sound alarms to others who may also encourage her to seek help. Any advice? Ex’s lawyer has all of the details, but we are concerned about taking any steps that would expose the details to the kids.
– Balancing Defense and Blame
A: You use “defense” in your signature, but Sister’s instability clears your name of her charges. She and the kids are far more at risk than your reputation is.
Enlisting others is a good idea, to help Sister get help. The affair is but one detail of many in her public cry for help, so you can sound the alarm without it. Continue updating the lawyer, but a mental health professional is the one you want making the call on how to protect these kids.